The public inquiry as a contested political technology: GM crop moratorium reviews in Australia
- 1 March 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Politics
- Vol. 22 (2) , 293-311
Abstract
In 2007, the Australian states of Victoria and New South Wales held reviews of their moratoriums on the commercial release of genetically modified (GM) food crops. The public inquiry form of review selected offered the best strategic pathway to amend these moratoriums to allow commercial release. As such, the reviews represented ‘political technologies’. This proposition is informed by: their formation within a policy context of pro-GM development, which saw ‘stacked’ pro-GM review panels, narrow terms of reference, and outcomes favouring a narrow coalition of agbiotechnology interests; the critical literature on public inquiries; and other evidences that suggest the underlying purpose of the public inquiries was to reach the inescapable conclusion that the moratoriums should be changed. While contributing to the literature on the public inquiry, particularly in relation to science, technology and environmental governance, these findings also invite the suggestion of new deliberative forms of the public inquiry to more adequately address legitimacy and policy effectiveness.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Science and citizenship: a new synergyScience and Public Policy, 2004
- Scientific Method Discourses in the Construction of `EMF Science'Social Studies of Science, 2002
- Representing and Managing Farmers' Interests in AustraliaSociologia Ruralis, 1999
- Sensemaking, communicative distortion and the logic of public inquiry legitimationIndustrial Crisis Quarterly, 1992
- Controversy and Closure: Sydney's Beaches in CrisisSocial Studies of Science, 1991
- Reckoning Schemes of Legitimation: On Commissions of Inquiry as Power/Knowledge FormsJournal of Historical Sociology, 1990
- ASSESSING COMPLEX TECHNICAL ISSUES: PUBLIC INQUIRIES OR COMMISSIONS?The Political Quarterly, 1988
- THE PRODIGAL TECHNOLOGY: NUCLEAR POWER AND POLITICAL CONTROVERSYThe Political Quarterly, 1988
- The fight for science textbooksNature, 1986
- PUBLIC INQUIRIES IN AUSTRALIA: AN OVERVIEWAustralian Journal of Public Administration, 1985