Bias in PM2.5 measurements using collocated reference-grade and optical instruments
Authors:
- 25 July 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
- Vol. 194 (9) , 1-14
Abstract
Optical PM2.5 measurements are sensitive to aerosol properties that can vary with space and time. Here, we compared PM2.5 measurements from collocated reference-grade (beta attenuation monitors, BAMs) and optical instruments (two DustTrak II and two DustTrak DRX) over 6 months. We performed inter-model (two different models), intra-model (two units of the same model), and inter-type (two different device types: optical vs. reference-grade) comparisons under ambient conditions. Averaged over our study period, PM2.5 measured concentrations were 46.0 and 45.5 μg m−3 for the two DustTrak II units, 29.8 and 38.4 μg m−3 for DRX units, and 18.3 and 19.0 μg m−3 for BAMs. The normalized root square difference (NRMSD; compares PM2.5 measurements from paired instruments of the same type) was ~ 5% (DustTrak II), ~ 27% (DRX), and ~ 15% (BAM). The normalized root mean square error (NRMSE; compares PM2.5 measurements from optical instruments against a reference instrument) was ~ 165% for DustTrak II, ~ 74% after applying literature-based humidity correction and ~ 27% after applying both the humidity and BAM corrections. Although optical instruments are highly precise in their PM2.5 measurements, they tend to be strongly biased relative to reference-grade devices. We also explored two different methods to compensate for relative humidity bias and found that the results differed by ~ 50% between the two methods. This study highlights the limitations of adopting a literature-derived calibration equation and the need for conducting local model-specific calibration. Moreover, this is one of the few studies to perform an intra-model comparison of collocated reference-grade devices.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparing Gravimetric and Real-Time Sampling of PM2.5Concentrations Inside Truck CabinsJournal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 2011
- Concentrations of fine, ultrafine, and black carbon particles in auto-rickshaws in New Delhi, IndiaAtmospheric Environment, 2011
- Spatiotemporal Aspects of Real-Time PM2.5: Low- and Middle-Income Neighborhoods in Bangalore, IndiaEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2011
- Correction Factor for Continuous Monitoring of Wood Smoke Fine Particulate MatterAerosol and Air Quality Research, 2011
- A Novel Optical Instrument for Estimating Size Segregated Aerosol Mass Concentration in Real TimeAerosol Science and Technology, 2009
- Winter comparison of TEOM, MiniVol and DustTrak PM10 monitors in a woodsmoke environmentAtmospheric Environment, 2006
- Comparison of Fine Particle Measurements from a Direct-Reading Instrument and a Gravimetric Sampling MethodJournal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 2004
- Performance evaluation of the active-flow personal DataRAM PM2.5 mass monitor (Thermo Anderson pDR-1200) designed for continuous personal exposure measurementsAtmospheric Environment, 2004
- A comparison of two direct-reading aerosol monitors with the federal reference method for PM2.5 in indoor airAtmospheric Environment, 2002
- Federal Reference and Equivalent Methods for Measuring Fine Particulate MatterAerosol Science and Technology, 2001