Separate and unequal: Prison versus free-world medical care
Authors:
- 1 March 1998
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Justice Quarterly
- Vol. 15 (1) , 3-40
Abstract
Rusche and Kirchheimer argued that attempts at penal reform are limited by a principle of less eligibility, by which the regimen of punishment is made harsher than the conditions of life among the least well-off members of the working classes. In addition, Black posited that the benefits of law are inversely related to stratification and morphology; that is, inmates would be entitled to fewer benefits in law than would free-world citizens. Today the penal harm movement strives to make prison life harder, asserting that comfortable prison conditions are responsible for high crime rates. Critics frequently blame judicial intervention in prison operations for upsetting the careful calibration necessary to deter crime. In this article we examine these assertions by focusing on medical care litigation. Comparing the legal rules and precedents used to hold prison physicians liable for inadequate medical care under 42 U.S.C., Section 1983 with the standards customarily employed by courts in evaluating medical malpractice in the free world, we conclude that judicial decisions in this vital area conform to what would be expected, given the operation of the principle of less eligibility and Black's “differentiation of law” thesis.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Civil liability against prison officials for prescribing and dispensing medication and drugs to prison inmatesJournal of Legal Medicine, 1997
- Prison Officials' Liability for Inmate-to-inmate AssaultJournal of Offender Rehabilitation, 1997
- Divided loyalties?—the police surgeon and criminal justicePolicing and Society, 1997
- Getting Tough on Prisoners: Results from the National Corrections Executive Survey, 1995Crime & Delinquency, 1997
- Current Trends in State Inmate User Fee Programs for Health ServicesJournal of Correctional Health Care, 1996
- A Preliminary Model for Determining Limits for Correctional Health Care ServicesJournal of Correctional Health Care, 1996
- PHYSICAL CONDITIONS AND PRISONER DEATHS: A CLINICAL REPORTJournal of Offender Rehabilitation, 1995
- Gazette of Morality and Social Whip: Punishment, Hegemony and the Case of the Usa, I970-92Social & Legal Studies, 1993
- Crises in British Prisons: A Critical Review EssayInternational Criminal Justice Review, 1993
- Identification of health care problems in a county jailJournal of Community Health, 1987