Correlation between Quantitative PCR and Culture-Based Methods for Measuring Enterococcus spp. over Various Temporal Scales at Three California Marine Beaches
- 15 February 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Society for Microbiology in Applied and Environmental Microbiology
- Vol. 78 (4) , 1237-1242
Abstract
Several studies have examined how fecal indicator bacteria (FIB) measurements compare between quantitative PCR (qPCR) and the culture methods it is intended to replace. Here, we extend those studies by examining the stability of that relationship within a beach, as affected by time of day and seasonal variations in source. Enterococcus spp. were quantified at three southern California beaches in the morning and afternoon using two qPCR assays, membrane filtration, and defined-substrate testing. While qPCR and culture-based measurements were consistently and significantly correlated, strength of the correlation varied both among and within beaches. Correlations were higher in the morning (0.45 < ρ < 0.74 [ P < 0.002]) than in the afternoon (0.18 < ρ < 0.45 [ P < 0.021]) and higher when the fecal contamination was concentrated (0.38 < ρ < 0.83 [ P < 0.001]) than when it was diffuse (0.19 < ρ < 0.34 [ P < 0.003]). The ratios of culture-based and qPCR results (CFU or most probable number [MPN] per calibrator cell equivalents [CCE]) also varied spatially and temporally. Ratios ranged between 0.04 and 0.85 CFU or MPN per CCE and were lowest at the beach affected by diffuse pollution. Patterns in the ratios over the course of the day were dissimilar across beaches, increasing with time at one beach and decreasing at another. The spatial and temporal variability we observed indicate that the empirical relationship between culture-based and qPCR results is not universal, even within a beach.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparison of Rapid Quantitative PCR-Based and Conventional Culture-Based Methods for Enumeration of Enterococcus spp. and Escherichia coli in Recreational WatersApplied and Environmental Microbiology, 2010
- Rapidly measured indicators of recreational water quality and swimming-associated illness at marine beaches: a prospective cohort studyEnvironmental Health, 2010
- Evaluation of Conventional and Alternative Monitoring Methods for a Recreational Marine Beach with Nonpoint Source of Fecal ContaminationEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2010
- Relationship and Variation of qPCR and Culturable Enterococci Estimates in Ambient Surface Waters Are PredictableEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2010
- Presence of Pathogens and Indicator Microbes at a Non-Point Source Subtropical Recreational Marine BeachApplied and Environmental Microbiology, 2010
- A cross comparison of QPCR to agar-based or defined substrate test methods for the determination of Escherichia coli and enterococci in municipal water quality monitoring programsWater Research, 2009
- A sea change ahead for recreational water quality criteriaJournal of Water and Health, 2008
- Rapidly Measured Indicators of Recreational Water Quality Are Predictive of Swimming-Associated Gastrointestinal IllnessEnvironmental Health Perspectives, 2006
- Decadal and Shorter Period Variability of Surf Zone Water Quality at Huntington Beach, CaliforniaEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2002
- A new mathematical model for relative quantification in real-time RT-PCRNucleic Acids Research, 2001