Agreement and compatibility in Wigner’s friend paradox
- 26 October 2026
- journal article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physica Scripta
- Vol. 101 (43) , 435101
Abstract
There has been an upsurge of interest in the consequences for quantum physics of the so-called Wigner’s Friend Paradox. In its original formulation, the paradox has been turned inside out, and virtually every aspect of it has been looked into. Consequently, it is becoming widely accepted that we can find the potentially puzzling consequences of Wigner’s thought experiment only in light of its many-parties extensions. Nonetheless, this contribution returns to the source. Reframing the question as an inference problem, we advance a radically Bayesian interpretation that shows no contradiction between Wigner’s and Wigner’s Friend’s descriptions—neither classically nor quantumly. Therefore, with no paradoxical conclusion. In doing so, we flesh out and expose previously untouched aspects of Wigner’s thought experiment, in particular, the fact that compatibility and agreement are fundamental to our understanding of it, and that a rigorous notion of compatibility is the key to paving the way for the agents to reach an agreement. Also, by conservatively extending Wigner’s original setup and incorporating what we call the’benefit of the doubt’, we see how either Wigner’s or his Friend’s description can be driven to match one another’s—an impossibility if either agent does not keep an open mind.Keywords
Funding Information
- John Templeton Foundation
- Programa Conhecimento Brasil (63209)
- CNPq
- CAPES
- Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Extracting quantum dynamical resources: consumption of non-Markovianity for noise reductionnpj Quantum Information, 2023
- The impossibility of agreeing to disagree: An extension of the sure-thing principleGames and Economic Behavior, 2022
- Observers of quantum systems cannot agree to disagreeNature Communications, 2021
- The View from a Wigner BubbleFoundations of Physics, 2021
- Determining eigenstates and thermal states on a quantum computer using quantum imaginary time evolutionNature Physics, 2019
- Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itselfNature Communications, 2018
- Quantum violation of an instrumental testNature Physics, 2017
- Agreeing to disagree in probabilistic dynamic epistemic logicSynthese, 2013
- How Do Two Observers Pool Their Knowledge About a Quantum System?Quantum Information Processing, 2002
- On the logic of “agreeing to disagree” type resultsJournal of Economic Theory, 1990