Efficacy and Profitability of Fungicide Application Timings for Septoria Brown Spot of Soybean in Ohio
- 1 October 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Scientific Societies in Plant Disease
- Vol. 110 (10) , 4338-4346
Abstract
Fungicide use against Septoria brown spot (SBS) is not routinely recommended in Ohio soybean production due to inconsistent yield responses and limited economic benefit. Previous studies have focused on reproductive-stage applications (R3: beginning pod; R5: beginning seed), while the value of prophylactic vegetative-stage (V5: fifth trifoliolate) applications remains unclear. This study evaluated fungicide program effects on SBS severity, seed yield, and economic responses across 16 naturally infested field environments in Ohio (2022 to 2024). Treatments included single applications of Priaxor (fluxapyroxad + pyraclostrobin) at V5; Revytek (mefentrifluconazole + fluxapyroxad + pyraclostrobin) at R3 or R5; and sequential programs combining V5 with R3 or R5 on four soybean cultivars differing in foliar disease resistance. Mixed-effects models accounted for environment-specific variation and fungicide-by-environment interactions. Overall, disease pressure was very low throughout the study period. Moderately resistant cultivars exhibited 19.7% lower SBS severity (95% CI: 6.9 to 30.8%) compared with moderately susceptible cultivars. Only single R3 applications significantly increased yield (131.0 kg ha −1 ; 95% CI: 38.2–223.8), whereas V5, R5, and sequential programs produced positive but nonsignificant gains. Economic analyses showed V5 applications generated net losses (−33.9 to −16.9 USD ha −1 ), and sequential programs were unprofitable across price scenarios. Single R3 application at the highest soybean price was the only economical strategy, with a 52.8% breakeven probability. V5 applications, though unprofitable, still outperformed R5 and sequential programs. For Ohio soybean producers, SBS management should prioritize scouting to guide targeted R3 fungicide applications. This approach proved more effective and economical than prophylactic or sequential programs. When available, selecting cultivars with foliar disease resistance can complement integrated SBS management.Keywords
Funding Information
- CFAES-IGP (2022-019)
- Ohio Soybean Council
- USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture (OHO01569)
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Inclusion of sulphur in fungicide programmes for integrated disease management of soybeanCanadian Journal of Plant Pathology, 2025
- Heteroscedasticity-aware stratified sampling to improve uplift modelingEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2025
- Efficacy and Profitability of Fungicides for Managing Frogeye Leaf Spot on Soybean in the United States: A 10-Year Quantitative SummaryPlant Disease, 2023
- A machine learning interpretation of the contribution of foliar fungicides to soybean yield in the north‐central United StatesScientific Reports, 2021
- Characterization of Septoria brown spot disease development and yield effects on soybean in IllinoisCanadian Journal of Plant Pathology, 2020
- Tillage system effect on the epidemic of soybean brown spotTropical Plant Pathology, 2015
- Historical gains in soybean (Glycine max Merr.) seed yield are driven by linear increases in light interception, energy conversion, and partitioning efficienciesJournal of Experimental Botany, 2014
- Brown Spot Severity and Yield of Soybeans Regenerated from Calli Resistant to a Host-Specific Pathotoxin Produced bySeptoria glycinesPlant Disease, 1996
- Reactions of Perennial Wild Species of Genus Glycine to Septoria glycinesPlant Disease, 1987
- Tillage effects on soil properties, diseases, cyst nematodes, and soybean yieldsJournal of Soil and Water Conservation, 1983