On the grammar of utterances: putting the form vs. substance distinction back on its feet
Authors:
- 2 January 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Acta Linguistica Hafniensia
- Vol. 48 (1) , 35-58
Abstract
Recent work in language theory, linguistic typology and usage-based linguistics has actualised the time-honoured distinction between ‘form’ (or ‘structure’) and ‘substance’, which was popular not least during classical European structuralism. This paper reviews some controversies within the theory of form and substance. Current dialogical theories of situated languaging, as well as many variants of functional, cognitive and other usage-based approaches, motivate a perspective shift in the language sciences, assigning primacy to language use (‘languaging’, ‘doing language’) rather than to abstract language systems. This gives more weight to ‘substance’, while it still necessitates the recognition of language structures. This paper makes an argument for a respecification of the relationships between form and substance, or between structuralist and substantialist conceptions, seen in relation to received versions. The empirical data adduced in this paper are drawn from conversational Swedish.Keywords
Funding Information
- Swedish Research Council
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evidence for a Dialogical Grammar: Reactive constructions in Swedish and German2014
- Calibrating the child for language: Meredith Williams on a Wittgensteinian approach to language socializationLanguage Sciences, 2013
- On the pivot turn construction method in Swedish and FinnishJournal of Pragmatics, 2013
- Optional expletive subjects in SwedishNordic Journal of Linguistics, 2012
- Emergent Grammar and Temporality in Interactional Linguistics2011
- First-Order Languaging Dynamics and Second-Order Language: The Distributed Language ViewEcological Psychology, 2011
- Projection and Minimalistic Syntax in InteractionDiscourse Processes, 2009
- On-line syntax: Thoughts on the temporality of spoken languageLanguage Sciences, 2009
- Cognition and the language mythLanguage Sciences, 2004
- Language and languagingLanguage & Communication, 1991