Tc-99m Sulfur Colloid and Tc-99m Tagged Red Blood Cell Methods Are Comparable for Detecting Lower Gastrointestinal Bleeding in Clinical Practice
Authors:
- Hongming ZhuangHZHongming Zhuang
- Frank M. LiuFLFrank M. Liu
- Lester B. LacorteLLLester B. Lacorte
- Bahar MoussavianBMBahar Moussavian
- Sunny WangSWSunny Wang
- Abass AlaviAAAbass Alavi
- 1 June 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Clinical Nuclear Medicine
- Vol. 27 (6) , 405-409
Abstract
The objective of this study was to determine whether the Tc-99m red blood cells (Tc-99m RBC) method has a true advantage over the Tc-99m sulfur colloid (Tc-99m SC) technique in a busy clinical practice for detecting and localizing lower gastrointestinal bleeding sites. Three hundred fifty-nine consecutive gastrointestinal bleeding studies performed during the past 4 years were reviewed retrospectively. One hundred ninety-three scans were obtained with Tc-99m SC (scan duration, 30 minutes) and 138 studies were performed after the administration of Tc-99m RBC (scan duration, 1 hour). In addition, 28 examinations with Tc-99m SC were followed immediately by Tc-99m RBC scans for a duration of several hours. The results of the two methods were analyzed and the performance of the two techniques was compared. Among 193 scans performed using the Tc-99m SC method, 47 (24.4%) successfully identified the location of the bleeding site, whereas in 138 scans performed using Tc-99m RBC, 38 (27.5%) were successful for this purpose. In the remaining 28 scans in which the Tc-99m SC scan was followed by the Tc-99m RBC study, only 4 (14.3%) positive bleeding sites were identified after a prolonged imaging period. The theoretical advantages of the Tc-99m RBC technique compared with the Tc-99m SC method cannot be substantiated by this study. Our findings suggest that the efficacy of these two methods is nearly equal at a practical level. The simpler and cost-effective Tc-99m SC method is as efficient as the Tc-99m RBC method when the scanning time is limited to 1 hour and optimal imaging and interpretation schemes are used.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Role of Tagged Red Blood Cell Imaging in the Localization of Gastrointestinal BleedingArchives of Surgery, 1991
- Limited value of technetium 99m-labeled red cell scintigraphy in localization of lower gastrointestinal bleedingThe American Journal of Surgery, 1990
- Comparison of Technetium-99m Sulfur Colloid and In Vitro Labeled Technetium-99m RBCs in the Detection of Gastrointestinal BleedingClinical Nuclear Medicine, 1985
- Scintigraphy of gastrointestinal hemorrhage: superiority of 99mTc red blood cells over 99mTc sulfur colloidAmerican Journal of Roentgenology, 1984
- Detection of gastrointestinal bleeding with 99mTc-sulfur colloidSeminars in Nuclear Medicine, 1982
- Gastrointestinal Bleeding: An Accessory Spleen Causing a False-positive Tc-99m- Sulfur Colloid StudyClinical Nuclear Medicine, 1982
- Localization of gastrointestinal bleeding: superiority of 99mTc sulfur colloid compared with angiographyAmerican Journal of Roentgenology, 1981
- Studies of GI bleeding with scintigraphy and the influence of vasopressinSeminars in Nuclear Medicine, 1981