A Time to Die: Mexican Life Debates and the Paradox of Choice in Palliative Care
Open Access
- 5 October 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry
- Vol. 49 (4) , 1286-1305
Abstract
Enduring contests between church, state, and individual control over the body in Mexico have recently manifested in a contentious “life debate” over the definition and ethics of “dignified death” (Roberts in God’s laboratory: assisted reproduction in the Andes. University of California Press, 2012). In 2008, Mexico City passed the Advance Directive Law, authorizing the right to refuse or withdraw life-sustaining treatment and affording palliative care services to the terminally ill through public hospitals. While these measures have ostensibly ameliorated end-of-life suffering, a growing movement of activists argues that the law falls short. They advocate for the legalization of assisted dying as central to “dignified death” despite resistance from the Catholic hierarchy and its political allies. Drawing on one year of research in Mexico’s National Cancer Institute, we analyze the place of public palliative care clinicians in this fraught debate, parsing their model of care, which is predicated on surrendering to the body’s preordained rhythms of life and death. We argue that this orientation gives rise to a paradox at the heart of public palliative care, which simultaneously expands end-of-life choices while making certain choices inconceivable. Our argument has implications for anthropological theories of human agency and choice, provoking complex questions about who is authorized to draw boundaries around life and death.Keywords
Funding Information
- Wenner-Gren Foundation (9716)
- National Science Foundation (2319715)
- Southern Methodist University
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Relationship of Palliative Care With Assisted Dying Where Assisted Dying is Lawful: A Systematic Scoping Review of the LiteratureJournal of Pain and Symptom Management, 2020
- Standing at the Doorstep: Affective Encounters in Research on Death and Dying2019
- On the (f)utility of painThe Lancet, 2015
- Permanent personhood or meaningful decline? Toward a critical anthropology of successful agingJournal of Aging Studies, 2014
- The State of Elder Care in MexicoCurrent Geriatrics Reports, 2012
- Hospital ethnography: introductionSocial Science & Medicine, 2004
- Good and bad death: IntroductionSocial Science & Medicine, 2004
- Dying peacefully: considering good death and bad death in Kwahu-Tafo, GhanaSocial Science & Medicine, 2004
- Good enough death: autonomy and choice in Australian palliative careSocial Science & Medicine, 2004
- Narrative nuances on good and bad deaths: internists’ tales from high-technology work placesSocial Science & Medicine, 2004