Modelling binary mixtures of herbicides in populations resistant to one of the components: evaluation for resistance management
Authors:
- 16 September 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Pest Management Science
- Vol. 65 (2) , 113-121
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Herbicide mixtures are commonly proposed to delay the selection of herbicide resistance in susceptible populations (called the SM strategy). However, in practice, herbicide mixtures are often used when resistance to one of the two active ingredients has already been detected in the targeted population (called the RM strategy). It is doubtful whether such a practice can select against resistance, as the corresponding selection pressure is still exerted. As a consequence, the effect of mixtures on the evolution of an already detected resistance to one of the herbicides in the combination remains largely unexplored. In the present work, a simple model was developed to explore further the necessary and sufficient conditions under which a binary RM strategy might stabilise or even reduce resistance frequency.RESULTS: Covering the hypothetical largest range of parameters, 39% of 9000 random simulations attest that the RM strategy might theoretically reduce resistance frequency. When strong enough, high genetic cost of resistance, negative cross‐resistance between the herbicides associated in the mixture and reduced selection differential between resistant and susceptible plants can counterbalance the resistance advantage to one of the two applied herbicides. However, the required conditions for an RM strategy to ensure resistance containment in natural conditions seldom overlap with experimental parameter estimates given in the literature.CONCLUSION: It is concluded that the sufficient conditions for an RM strategy to be effective would rarely be encountered. As a consequence, the strategy of formulating mixtures with herbicides for which resistance has already been detected should be avoided. Copyright © 2008 Society of Chemical IndustryKeywords
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- Combinations of several insecticides used for integrated control of Colorado potato beetle (Leptinotarsa decemlineata, Say., Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae)Journal of Pest Science, 2006
- Building of an Experimental Cline With Arabidopsis thaliana to Estimate Herbicide Fitness CostGenetics, 2006
- Epistatic Interactions Among Herbicide Resistances in Arabidopsis thaliana: The Fitness Cost of MultiresistanceGenetics, 2005
- Resistance to ACCase inhibitor herbicides in a green foxtail (Setaria viridis) biotype in EuropeWeed Science, 2004
- Response of acetolactate synthase from imidazolinone-susceptible and -resistant smooth pigweed toALS inhibitorsWeed Science, 2002
- Antibiotic and insecticide resistance modeling – is it time to start talking?Trends in Microbiology, 2001
- Management strategies for attenuating herbicide resistance: untoward consequences of their promotionCrop Protection, 2000
- Fitness effects of the triazine resistance mutation in Amaranthus hybridus: relative fitness in maize and soyabean cropsWeed Research, 1999
- When can Reduced Doses and Pesticide Mixtures Delay the Build-up of Pesticide Resistance? A Mathematical ModelJournal of Applied Ecology, 1997
- Theoretical analysis of the effect of interacting activities on the rate of selection for combined resistance to fungicide mixturesCrop Protection, 1993