Cannulated screws versus dynamic hip screw versus hemiarthroplasty versus total hip arthroplasty in patients with displaced and non-displaced femoral neck fractures: a systematic review and frequentist network meta-analysis of 5703 patients
Open Access
- 26 August 2023
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research
- Vol. 18 (1) , 1-30
Abstract
Background: Our aim was to determine the best operative procedure in human participants with a displaced or non-displaced femoral neck fracture comparing cannulated screw (CS) fixation, dynamic hip screw (DHS) fixation, hemiarthroplasty (HA), and total hip arthroplasty (THA) in terms of surgical and functional outcomes, reoperation and postoperative complications. Methods: We searched PubMed, The Cochrane Library, Clinical trials, CINAHL, and Embase for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) or quasi-RCTs up to 31 July 2022. A frequentist network meta-analysis was performed to assess the comparative effects of the four operative procedures, using fixed-effects and random-effects models. Mean differences (MDs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were estimated for continuous variables and odds ratios (ORs) with 95% CIs were estimated for binary variables. Results: A total of 33 RCTs with 5703 patients were included in our network meta-analysis. CS fixation was best in terms of operation time (CS: MD = − 57.70, 95% CI − 72.78; − 42.62; DHS: MD = − 53.56, 95% CI − 76.17; − 30.95; HA: MD = − 20.90, 95% CI − 30.65; − 11.15; THA: MD = 1.00 reference) and intraoperative blood loss (CS: MD = − 3.67, 95% CI − 4.44; − 2.90; DHS: MD = − 3.20, 95% CI − 4.97; − 1.43; HA: MD = − 1.20, 95% CI − 1.73; − 0.67; THA: MD = 1.00 reference). In life quality and functional outcome, measured at different time points with EQ-5D and the Harris Hip Score (HHS), THA ranked first and HA second (e.g. EQ-5D 2 years postoperatively: CS: MD = − 0.20, 95% CI − 0.29; − 0.11; HA: MD = − 0.09, 95% CI − 0.17; − 0.02; THA: MD = 1.00 reference; HHS 2 years postoperatively: CS: MD = − 5.50, 95% CI − 9.98; − 1.03; DHS: MD = − 8.93, 95% CI − 15.08; − 2.78; HA: MD = − 3.65, 95% CI − 6.74; − 0.57; THA: MD = 1.00 reference). CS fixation had the highest reoperation risk, followed by DHS fixation, HA, and THA (CS: OR = 9.98, 95% CI 4.60; 21.63; DHS: OR = 5.07, 95% CI 2.15; 11.96; HA: OR = 1.60, 95% CI 0.89; 2.89; THA: OR = 1.00 reference). Conclusion: In our cohort of patients with displaced and non-displaced femoral neck fractures, HHS, EQ-5D, and reoperation risk showed an advantage of THA and HA compared with CS and DHS fixation. Based on these findings, we recommend that hip arthroplasty should be preferred and internal fixation of femoral neck fractures should only be considered in individual cases. Level of evidence I: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Trial registration: PROSPERO on 10 August 2022 (CRD42022350293).Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Medizinische Hochschule Brandenburg CAMPUS gGmbH
This publication has 77 references indexed in Scilit:
- Psychometric Properties of Patient-Reported Outcome Measures for Hip Arthroscopic SurgeryThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2013
- Prospective randomized controlled trial comparing dynamic hip screw and screw fixation for undisplaced subcapital hip fracturesAnz Journal of Surgery, 2012
- Total hip arthroplasty versus hemiarthroplasty for displaced femoral neck fractures in the healthy elderly: a meta-analysis and systematic review of randomized trialsInternational Orthopaedics, 2012
- Total hip replacement and hemiarthroplasty in mobile, independent patients with a displaced intracapsular fracture of the femoral neckThe Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British volume, 2011
- A comparison of hemiarthroplasty with total hip replacement for displaced intracapsular fracture of the femoral neckThe Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British volume, 2010
- Total Hip Arthroplasty is Less Painful at 12 Months Compared with Hemiarthroplasty in Treatment of Displaced Femoral Neck FractureHSS Journal®: The Musculoskeletal Journal of Hospital for Special Surgery, 2008
- Hemiarthroplasty or internal fixation for intracapsular displaced femoral neck fractures: randomised controlled trialBMJ, 2007
- The four-year functional result after a displaced subcapital hip fracture treated with three different surgical optionsInternational Orthopaedics, 2007
- Internal fixation compared with total hip replacement for displaced femoral neck fractures in the elderlyThe Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British volume, 2003
- Internal fixation versus total hip arthroplasty in the treatment of displaced femoral neck fractures: A prospective randomized study of 100 hipsActa Orthopaedica, 2000