What is the added value of combined core biopsy and fine needle aspiration in the diagnostic process of renal tumours?
Authors:
Open Access
- 28 May 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 31 (4) , 823-827
Abstract
Purpose Non-diagnostic results still hinder the routine use of core biopsy (CB) and fine needle aspiration (FNA) in the diagnostic process of renal tumours. Furthermore, substantial interobserver variability has been reported. We assessed the added value of combining the results of CB and FNA by five pathologists in the ex vivo diagnosis of renal mass. Methods Two ex vivo core biopsies were taken followed by two FNA passes from extirpated tumours. All samples were evaluated by five blinded pathologists. A consensus diagnosis of the surgical specimen was the index for comparison. For each pathologist, the number of non-diagnostic (non-conclusive or undetermined biology and failed biopsies), correct and incorrect scored cases of each technique was assessed. When a non-diagnostic CB or FNA had a correct diagnostic counterpart, this was considered as of added value. Results Of the 57 assessed tumours, 53 were malignant. CB was non-diagnostic in 4–10 cases (7–17.5%). FNA established the correct diagnosis in 1–7 of these cases. FNA was non-diagnostic in 2–6 cases (3.5–10.5%), and the counterpart CB established the correct diagnosis in 1–6 of these cases. For the 5 pathologists, accuracy of CB and FNA varied between 82.5–93% and 89.5–96.5%, respectively. Combination of both types of biopsy resulted in 55–57 correct results (accuracy 96.5–100%), i.e., an increase in accuracy of 3.5–14%. Conclusion Combining the result of CB and FNA in renal mass biopsy leads to a higher diagnostic accuracy. Recommendations on which technique used should be adapted to local expertise and logistic possibilities.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Current role, techniques and outcomes of percutaneous biopsy of renal tumorsExpert Review of Anticancer Therapy, 2009
- Editorial Comment on: Cytological Punctures in the Diagnosis of Renal Tumours: A Study on Accuracy and ReproducibilityEuropean Urology, 2009
- Biopsies and Cytological Punctures2008
- Diagnostic Accuracy of Computed Tomography-Guided Percutaneous Biopsy of Renal MassesEuropean Urology, 2008
- Renal Mass Biopsy—A Renaissance?Journal of Urology, 2008
- Percutaneous needle biopsy for indeterminate renal masses: a national survey of UK consultant urologistsBMC Urology, 2007
- Nephron-Sparing Surgery and Percutaneous Biopsies in Renal-Cell Carcinoma: A Global Impression among EndourologistsJournal of Endourology, 2007
- Handling and pathology reporting of specimens with carcinoma of the urinary bladder, ureter, and renal pelvis. A joint proposal of the European Society of Uropathology and the Uropathology Working GroupVirchows Archiv, 2004
- Solid Renal Tumors: An Analysis of Pathological Features Related to Tumor SizeJournal of Urology, 2003
- IMAGING GUIDED BIOPSY OF RENAL MASSES: INDICATIONS, ACCURACY AND IMPACT ON CLINICAL MANAGEMENTJournal of Urology, 1999