Man against machine: Do fungal fruitbodies and eDNA give similar biodiversity assessments across broad environmental gradients?
Preprint
Abstract
The majority of Earths biodiversity is unknown. This is particularly true for the vast part of soil biodiversity, which rarely can be observed directly. Metabarcoding of DNA extracted from the environment (eDNA) has become state-of-the-art in assessing soil biodiversity. Also for fungal community profiling eDNA is seen as an attractive alternative to classical surveying based on fruitbodies. However, it is unknown whether eDNA-metabarcoding provides a representative sample of fungal diversity and census of threatened species. Therefore conservation planning and assessment are still based on fruitbody inventories. Based on a dataset of unprecedented width and depth, representing both soil eDNA-metabarcoding and expert inventorying of fungal fruitbodies, we document for the first time the validity of eDNA as practical inventory method and measure of conservation value for fungi. Fruitbody data identified fewer species in total and per site, and had larger variance in site richness. Focusing on macrofungi – the class Agaricomycetes, and in turn the order Agaricales – metrics of total richness and compositional similarity converged between the methods. eDNA was suboptimal for recording the non-soil dwelling fungi. β-diversity was similar between methods, but more variation in community composition could be explained by environmental predictors in eDNA data. The fruitbody survey was slightly better in finding red-listed species. We find a better correspondence between biodiversity indices derived from fungal fruitbodies and DNA-based approaches than indicated in earlier studies. We argue that (historical) fungal community data based on fruitbody forays – with careful selection of taxonomic groups – may be interpreted together with modern DNA-based approaches.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Biological Conservation, 233, 201.
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Towards next‐generation biodiversity assessment using DNA metabarcodingMolecular Ecology, 2012
- Insidious effects of sequencing errors on perceived diversity in molecular surveysNew Phytologist, 2010
- Phylogenetic and ecological analyses of soil and sporocarp DNA sequences reveal high diversity and strong habitat partitioning in the boreal ectomycorrhizal genus Russula (Russulales; Basidiomycota)New Phytologist, 2010
- Taxonomy and evolutionary relationships within species of section Rimosae (Inocybe) based on ITS, LSU and mtSSU sequence dataPersoonia - Molecular Phylogeny and Evolution of Fungi, 2009
- Factors of species-specific detectability in conservation assessments of poorly studied taxa: The case of polypore fungiBiological Conservation, 2009
- Molecular phylogenetic biodiversity assessment of arctic and boreal ectomycorrhizal Lactarius Pers. (Russulales; Basidiomycota) in Alaska, based on soil and sporocarp DNAMolecular Ecology, 2009
- Mining metadata from unidentified ITS sequences in GenBank: A case study in Inocybe (Basidiomycota)BMC Ecology and Evolution, 2008
- Species indicator values as an important tool in applied plant ecology – a reviewBasic and Applied Ecology, 2003
- Ectomycorrhizal community structure in a limed spruce forestMycological Research, 1999
- Macrofungal flora of Swedish beech forest related to soil organic matter and acidity characteristicsForest Ecology and Management, 1985