Transatlantic comparison of the competence of surgeons at the start of their professional career
Open Access
- 21 January 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in British Journal of Surgery
- Vol. 97 (3) , 443-449
Abstract
Background: Although the objective in European Union and North American surgical residency programmes is similar—to train competent surgeons—residents' working hours are different. It was hypothesized that practice-ready surgeons with more working hours would perform significantly better than those being educated within shorter working week curricula. Methods: At each test site, 21 practice-ready candidate surgeons were recruited. Twenty qualified Canadian and 19 qualified Dutch surgeons served as examiners. At both sites, three validated outcome instruments assessing multiple aspects of surgical competency were used. Results: No significant differences were found in performance on the integrative and cognitive examination (Comprehensive Integrative Puzzle) or the technical skills test (Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skill; OSATS). A significant difference in outcome was observed only on the Patient Assessment and Management Examination, which focuses on skills needed to manage patients with complex problems (P < 0·001). A significant interaction was observed between examiner and candidate origins for both task-specific OSATS checklist (P = 0·001) and OSATS global rating scale (P < 0·001) scores. Conclusion: Canadian residents, serving many more working hours, perform equivalently to Dutch residents when assessed on technical skills and cognitive knowledge, but outperformed Dutch residents in skills for patient management. Secondary analyses suggested that cultural differences influence the assessment process significantly.Keywords
Funding Information
- Richard and Elizabeth Currie Chair in Health Professions Education Research
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Impact of Work Hour Restrictions on Surgical Resident EducationJournal of Surgical Education, 2008
- Current Status and Future Perspective of General Surgical Trainees in the NetherlandsWorld Journal of Surgery, 2007
- Myths and Realities of the 80-Hour Work WeekCurrent Surgery, 2006
- Residents?? Perceptions of the Effects of Work Hour Limitations at a Large Teaching HospitalAcademic Medicine, 2006
- How much time do surgical residents need to learn operative surgery?The American Journal of Surgery, 2005
- Surgical residents' perceptions of the effects of the ACGME duty hour requirements 1 year after implementationSurgery, 2005
- Does Resident Hours Reduction Have an Impact on Surgical Outcomes?1Journal of Surgical Research, 2005
- Impact of Work-Hour Restrictions on Residents’ Operative Volume on a Subspecialty Surgical ServiceJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2005
- The Debate over Residents' Work HoursNew England Journal of Medicine, 2002
- Effects of Limited Work Hours on Surgical TrainingJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2002