Positionality Statements as a Function of Coloniality: Interrogating Reflexive Methodologies
Authors:
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 14 March 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Studies Quarterly
- Vol. 68 (2)
Abstract
S: Declaration of positionality and the confession of privilege as a way of revealing unequal power dynamics in knowledge production has become an increasingly encouraged reflexive practice in international relations and other disciplines. However, we interrogate the potentially negative implications of this methodology, occurring through a reification of material, assumed, and imagined hierarchies between people, which then is advertised and (re)produced by its utterance. We further query the modernist origins of reflexive methodology, which has inspired the practice of declaring positionality, and argue that its underpinning coloniality has bearings for its use today. We then explore how this coloniality manifests: Thus, first, we consider the extent to which publicly acknowledging privilege paradoxically acts as a means of centering whiteness through the narcissistic gaze and an assertion of legitimacy. Second, we argue positionality statements offer a redemption of guilt for the hegemonic researcher. And lastly, rather than ameliorating unequal power dynamics in the production of knowledge, we contend positionality statements may constitute hidden power moves in which one is able to signal and reinstate one’s authority vis-à-vis people, but especially women, of color. We end with a call for a reparative scholarship that acknowledges these limitations in positionality statements.Keywords
This publication has 86 references indexed in Scilit:
- The coloniality of the religious terrorism thesisReview of International Studies, 2023
- A letter to BabaReview of International Studies, 2023
- African Studies Keyword: AutoethnographyAfrican Studies Review, 2022
- Vernacular Rights Cultures2021
- From the Colonial to Feminist IR: Feminist IR Studies, the Wider FSS/GPE Research Agenda, and the Questions of Value, Valuation, Security, and ViolencePolitics & Gender, 2017
- Affective Communities in World Politics2016
- Reason and Emotion in International Ethics2014
- Autoethnographic International Relations: exploring the self as a source of knowledgeReview of International Studies, 2010
- Studying the struggles and wishes of the age: feminist theoretical methodology and feminist theoretical methods2006
- Reflexivity, feminism and differenceQualitative Sociology, 1993