Two methods are presented for sensitive measurement of nonreciprocal phase shift (NRPS) in a multi-turn fiber Sagnac interferometer for application in inertial rotation sensing. Both techniques are capable of producing an NRPS modulation of amplitude ±π/2 radians at a rate sufficiently high for shot-noise-limited performance. The first method produces an NRPS by generating a nonreciprocal refractive index using the electro-optic effect, and requires orthogonal polarization in the cw and ccw beams. The second method produces an NRPS by generating a nonreciprocal propagation frequency using two acousto-optic shifters; there is no requirement on light polarization. When either method is used in conjunction with phase-sensitive detection, feedback compensation, and adequate laser intensity, shot-noise-limited measurement becomes possible. Preliminary performance data is included.