We determine the most general three-dimensional vacuum spacetime with a negative cosmological constant containing a non-singular Killing horizon. We show that this includes an infinite class of asymptotically anti-de Sitter extreme black hole solutions which are neither stationary nor axisymmetric, but possess a single Killing field normal to the horizon. This is a generalisation of the extreme BTZ black hole, which carries arbitrary charges with respect to one of the asymptotic-symmetry Virasoro algebras and vanishing charges with respect to the other.