Parkinsonian Hand or Clinician’s Eye? Finger Tap Bradykinesia Interrater Reliability for 21 Movement Disorder Experts
Authors:
Open Access
- 17 April 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Parkinson’s Disease
- Vol. 13 (4) , 525-536
Abstract
Background: Bradykinesia is considered the fundamental motor feature of Parkinson’s disease (PD). It is central to diagnosis, monitoring, and research outcomes. However, as a clinical sign determined purely by visual judgement, the reliability of humans to detect and measure bradykinesia remains unclear. Objective: To establish interrater reliability for expert neurologists assessing bradykinesia during the finger tapping test, without cues from additional examination or history. Methods: 21 movement disorder neurologists rated finger tapping bradykinesia, by Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale (MDS-UPDRS) and Modified Bradykinesia Rating Scale (MBRS), in 133 videos of hands: 73 from 39 people with idiopathic PD, 60 from 30 healthy controls. Each neurologist rated 30 randomly-selected videos. 19 neurologists were also asked to judge whether the hand was PD or control. We calculated intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) for absolute agreement and consistency of MDS-UPDRS ratings, using standard linear and cumulative linked mixed models. Results: There was only moderate agreement for finger tapping MDS-UPDRS between neurologists, ICC 0.53 (standard linear model) and 0.65 (cumulative linked mixed model). Among control videos, 53% were rated > 0 by MDS-UPDRS, and 24% were rated as bradykinesia by MBRS subscore combination. Neurologists correctly identified PD/control status in 70% of videos, without strictly following bradykinesia presence/absence. Conclusion: Even experts show considerable disagreement about the level of bradykinesia on finger tapping, and frequently see bradykinesia in the hands of those without neurological disease. Bradykinesia is to some extent a phenomenon in the eye of the clinician rather than simply the hand of the person with PD.Keywords
This publication has 62 references indexed in Scilit:
- Finger Tapping Clinimetric Score Prediction in Parkinson's Disease Using Low-Cost AccelerometersComputational Intelligence and Neuroscience, 2013
- Hypokinesia without decrement distinguishes progressive supranuclear palsy from Parkinson's diseaseBrain, 2012
- Finger tapping movements of Parkinson’s disease patients automatically rated using nonlinear delay differential equationsChaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science, 2012
- The modified bradykinesia rating scale for Parkinson's disease: Reliability and comparison with kinematic measuresMovement Disorders, 2011
- Nonlinear dynamic analysis of oscillatory repetitive movements in Parkinson's disease and essential tremorMovement Disorders, 2010
- Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale‐Motor Exam: inter‐rater reliability of advanced practice nurse and neurologist assessmentsJournal of Advanced Nursing, 2010
- Measurement and Evaluation of Finger Tapping Movements Using Log-linearized Gaussian Mixture NetworksSensors, 2009
- Objective monitoring of tremor and bradykinesia during DBS surgery for Parkinson diseaseNeurology, 2008
- Unilateral versus bilateral tasks in early asymmetric Parkinson's disease: Differential effects on bradykinesiaMovement Disorders, 2007
- Influence of age, gender, education and dexterity on upper limb motor performance in Parkinsonian patients and healthy controlsJournal of Neural Transmission, 2003