Comparison of radii sets, entropy, QM methods, and sampling on MM‐PBSA, MM‐GBSA, and QM/MM‐GBSA ligand binding energies of F. tularensis enoyl‐ACP reductase (FabI)
- 27 July 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Computational Chemistry
- Vol. 36 (25) , 1859-1873
Abstract
To validate a method for predicting the binding affinities of FabI inhibitors, three implicit solvent methods, MM‐PBSA, MM‐GBSA, and QM/MM‐GBSA were carefully compared using 16 benzimidazole inhibitors in complex with Francisella tularensis FabI. The data suggests that the prediction results are sensitive to radii sets, GB methods, QM Hamiltonians, sampling protocols, and simulation length, if only one simulation trajectory is used for each ligand. In this case, QM/MM‐GBSA using 6 ns MD simulation trajectories together with GBneck2, PM3, and the mbondi2 radii set, generate the closest agreement with experimental values (r2 = 0.88). However, if the three implicit solvent methods are averaged from six 1 ns MD simulations for each ligand (called “multiple independent sampling”), the prediction results are relatively insensitive to all the tested parameters. Moreover, MM/GBSA together with GBHCT and mbondi, using 600 frames extracted evenly from six 0.25 ns MD simulations, can also provide accurate prediction to experimental values (r2 = 0.84). Therefore, the multiple independent sampling method can be more efficient than a single, long simulation method. Since future scaffold expansions may significantly change the benzimidazole's physiochemical properties (charges, etc.) and possibly binding modes, which may affect the sensitivities of various parameters, the relatively insensitive “multiple independent sampling method” may avoid the need of an entirely new validation study. Moreover, due to large fluctuating entropy values, (QM/)MM‐P(G)BSA were limited to inhibitors’ relative affinity prediction, but not the absolute affinity. The developed protocol will support an ongoing benzimidazole lead optimization program.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institutes of Health (U01 AI077949)
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Discovery of a Novel and Potent Class of F. tularensis Enoyl-Reductase (FabI) Inhibitors by Molecular Shape and Electrostatic MatchingJournal of Medicinal Chemistry, 2011
- Assessing the Performance of the MM/PBSA and MM/GBSA Methods. 1. The Accuracy of Binding Free Energy Calculations Based on Molecular Dynamics SimulationsJournal of Chemical Information and Modeling, 2010
- The R.E.D. tools: advances in RESP and ESP charge derivation and force field library buildingPhysical Chemistry Chemical Physics, 2010
- Characterizing Loop Dynamics and Ligand Recognition in Human- and Avian-Type Influenza Neuraminidases via Generalized Born Molecular Dynamics and End-Point Free Energy CalculationsJournal of the American Chemical Society, 2009
- Slow-Onset Inhibition of the FabI Enoyl Reductase from Francisella tularensis: Residence Time and in Vivo ActivityACS Chemical Biology, 2009
- Optimization of parameters for semiempirical methods V: Modification of NDDO approximations and application to 70 elementsJournal of Molecular Modeling, 2007
- Implementation of the SCC-DFTB Method for Hybrid QM/MM Simulations within the Amber Molecular Dynamics PackageThe Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 2007
- Generalized Born Model with a Simple, Robust Molecular Volume CorrectionJournal of Chemical Theory and Computation, 2006
- Development and testing of a general amber force fieldJournal of Computational Chemistry, 2004
- A well-behaved electrostatic potential based method using charge restraints for deriving atomic charges: the RESP modelThe Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1993