Meritocracy, deficit thinking and the invisibility of the system: Discourses on educational success and failure
- 8 July 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in British Educational Research Journal
- Vol. 40 (5) , 796-819
Abstract
Socio‐ethnic stratification and segregation processes present in Flemish society are reflected in the everyday school environment. Pupils with a different socio‐ethnic background than the dominant majority and middle class seem to be confronted with a lot of difficulties in this school system. The dominant meritocratic discourse frequently applies a deficit thinking perspective to frame educational success and failure, focusing on deficiencies originating outside of the school. In this paper we analyse newly collected survey data (N = 11,015 pupils) and a large amount of qualitative data (from pupils, parents, teachers, principals) to answer our two main research questions: (i) how is educational success/failure defined, and (ii) how is educational success/failure explained? The factor analyses as well as the qualitative analyses illustrate how the idea of meritocracy relates to individualistic features such as effort, merit and competence. However, the findings also reveal that this individualistic approach goes hand‐in‐hand with a focus on the family environment and ‘culture’ which seems to limit individual agency to a large extent. In these discourses, pupils, parents and even teachers are presented as being largely determined by their direct social environment with almost no regard for social inequalities within the educational system. The paper ends with a discussion on how processes of victimization and the denial of systemic bias, influence educational trajectories and proposes a different approach to multiculturalism and the appreciation of cultural background and specific family resources as positive elements in these trajectories.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Theorizing identity: beyond the ‘us’ and ‘them’ dichotomyPatterns of Prejudice, 2010
- Study Involvement of Academic and Vocational Students: Does Between-School Tracking Sharpen the Difference?American Educational Research Journal, 2009
- Researching Race/Ethnicity and Educational Inequality in English Secondary Schools: A Critical Review of the Research Literature Between 1980 and 2005Review of Educational Research, 2007
- Critical Race Theory and Education: Racism and anti-racism in educational theory and praxisDiscourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 2006
- The discourse of denial: how white teacher candidates construct race, racism and ‘white privilege’Race Ethnicity and Education, 2005
- "Mexican Americans Don't Value Education!" On the Basis of the Myth, Mythmaking, and DebunkingJournal of Latinos and Education, 2002
- From the Other Side of the Desk: Notes on teaching about race when racialisedRace Ethnicity and Education, 2002
- Agency and CultureJournal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 2000
- Minority Education in Comparative PerspectiveThe Journal of Negro Education, 1990
- Beyond the Correspondence Theory: Notes on the Dynamics of Educational Reproduction and TransformationCurriculum Inquiry, 1980