The state of global surgery assessment and data collection tools: A scoping review
Open Access
- 28 October 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in World Journal of Surgery
- Vol. 48 (12) , 2972-2989
Abstract
Background: There has been a proliferation of global surgery assessment tools designed for use in low‐ and middle‐income countries. This scoping review sought to categorize and organize the breadth of global surgery assessment tools in the literature.Methods: The search was conducted using PubMed from October 2022 to April 2023 according to PRISMA extension for scoping review guidelines. The search terms were ((“global surgery”[All Fields]) AND (“assessment”[All Fields]) OR (data collection)). Only tools published in English that detailed surgical assessment tools designed for low‐ and middle‐income countries were included.Results: The search resulted in 963 papers and 46 texts described unique tools that were included for the final review. Of these, 30 (65%) tools were quantitative, 1 (2%) qualitative, and 15 (33%) employed mixed‐methods. 25 (54%) tools evaluated surgery in general, whereas 21 (46%) were focused on various surgical subspecialties. Qualitatively, major themes among the tools were noted. There was significant overlap of many tools.Conclusions: Nonspecialty surgery was represented more than any specialty surgery and many specialties had little or no representation in the literature. Ideally, local leadership should be involved in surgical assessment tools. Different methodologies, such as checklists and observational studies, aimed to target varying aspects of surgery and had distinct strengths and weaknesses. Further efforts should focus on expanding tools in neglected specialties.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Development and content validation of the Safe Surgery Organizational Readiness Tool: A quality improvement studyInternational Journal of Surgery, 2021
- Identifying essential components of surgical care delivery through quality improvement: An updated surgical assessment toolInternational Journal of Surgery, 2020
- Development of a Needs Assessment Tool to Promote Capacity Building in Hand Surgery Outreach Trips: A Methodological Triangulation ApproachThe Journal of Hand Surgery, 2020
- Development of a surgical assessment tool for national policy monitoring & evaluation in Ethiopia: A quality improvement studyInternational Journal of Surgery, 2020
- A systematic review of capacity assessment tools in pediatric surgery: Global Assessment in Pediatric Surgery (GAPS) Phase IJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 2019
- Mixed-methods assessment of surgical capacity in two regions in EthiopiaBritish Journal of Surgery, 2019
- Strategic assessment of the availability of pediatric trauma care equipment, technology and supplies in GhanaJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 2015
- The International Assessment of Capacity for Trauma (INTACT): an index for trauma capacity in low-income countriesJournal of Surgical Research, 2014
- Pediatric emergency and essential surgical care in Zambian hospitals: A nationwide studyJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 2013
- Operative Mortality in Resource-Limited SettingsArchives of Surgery, 2010