On the Middle-Seed Anomaly for Single-Elimination Tournaments
Preprint
- 1 August 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
We investigate the phenomenon known as the "middle-seed anomaly", which is the statistical fact that it is better to be a 10, 11 or 12 seed than an 8 or 9 seed in the NCAA Division I Men's and Women's Basketball March Madness Tournament. We use simulations to show that this anomaly persists beyond 16-team tournaments and applies to single-elimination tournaments of any size where the number of players is a power of two. We show which rounds of the tournament the anomaly occurs and estimate that some lower-seeds have over a 10% greater chance of reaching later rounds compared to some higher-seeds. This demonstrates that given certain distributions of player strength, the standard seeding may not provide the most fair tournament.Keywords
This publication has 4 references indexed in Scilit:
- Stochastic transitivity: Axioms and modelsJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 2018
- A new knockout tournament seeding method and its axiomatic justificationOperations Research Letters, 2016
- Anomalies in Tournament Design: The Madness of March MadnessJournal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports, 2010
- What Is the Correct Way to Seed a Knockout Tournament?The American Mathematical Monthly, 2000