Media Criticism as Competitive Discourse
Author:
- 26 March 2009
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Communication Inquiry
- Vol. 33 (3) , 258-277
Abstract
This article treats media criticism as a specific form of discourse that aspires to define what journalism is, what it should aspire to, and who should speak about it. Recognizing journalists' cultural role of creating shared meaning, criticism either strives to uphold journalistic norms and isolate problematic incidents as deviant or calls attention to a faulty underlying framework of news production and presents foundational alternatives. Aside from being competitive discourse, media criticism is also collective by constructing various groups through its discourse by addressing specific audiences in an effort to create boundaries of acceptability. As a site for inquiry, the article tracks criticism surrounding reportage of the Abu Ghraib prison abuse scandal in April and May of 2004. Specific critical arguments regarding the scandal are systematically examined in four different spheres: within the news, the journalism trade press, from the left, and from the right.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Circling the WagonsJournal of Communication Inquiry, 2007
- When the Press Fails2007
- We the media2004
- Bad Apples: Paradigm Overhaul and the CNN/Time “Tailwind” StoryJournal of Communication Inquiry, 2002
- Doing double dutyJournalism, 2000
- Journalists as interpretive communitiesCritical Studies in Mass Communication, 1993
- The news paradigm and the ideology of objectivity: A socialist at the wall street journalCritical Studies in Mass Communication, 1990
- Toward a Theory of Press-State Relations in the United StatesJournal of Communication, 1990
- Repairing the News: A case Study of the News ParadigmJournal of Communication, 1985
- Outline of a Theory of Practice1977