Bioink fillers for printing bone implants should ideally be single-phase nanoscale hydroxyapatite (HAp) with a calcium-deficient stoichiometry and trace elements, and biogenic HAp (bHAp) derived from bovine and porcine bone potentially meets these requirements. This study substantiates the calcination temperature of bHAp (650, 750, and 850 °C) in terms of phase composition, dispersity, and similarity to the mineral phase of human tissues. The samples were compared with two synthetic HAp powders and with human diaphyseal bone, mandible, dentin, and enamel using X-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS). At 750 °C, bHAp was single-phase, with a crystallite (coherent scattering region) size of 39–46 nm and a Ca/P ratio of 1.55–1.56, and Mg and Zn were retained; the lattice parameters of bovine bHAp concurred with those of human diaphyseal bone. At 850 °C, the Ca/P ratio diverged (1.43 and 1.78) and the grains coarsened. The synthetic samples were nanosized (crystallite size 14–18 nm) but poorly crystalline and devoid of trace elements. The suitability of both HAp types as bioink fillers was analyzed: synthetic HAp for low-filler photopolymer inks and bHAp for extrusion bioinks with a higher filler content. Particle size distribution, rheology, and cytocompatibility have not yet been determined; these conclusions are therefore a prognosis. A screening life cycle assessment for 750 °C gave 8.62 kg CO2-eq. per 100 g of bHAp for the Czech electricity grid (3.62 kg CO2-eq. for Ukraine, 2023, lower bound); 97% of the footprint is attributable to electricity and 55% to calcination.