Response to Schrag: What are ethics committees for anyway? A defence of social science research ethics review
Author:
- 6 June 2012
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Research Ethics
- Vol. 8 (2) , 87-96
Abstract
Zachary Schrag would like to put the burden of proof for continuation of research ethics review in the Social Sciences on those who advocate for research ethics committees (RECs), and asks that we take the concerns that he raises seriously. I separate his concerns into a principled issue and a number of pragmatic issues. The principled issue concerns the justification for having research ethics committees; the pragmatic issues concern questions such as the effectiveness of review and the expertise of the committee members. I argue that RECs can be justified by their role in improving ethical practice and in reducing wrongs done to research participants. I propose a model of review for doing this, which I think would also address the pragmatic issues raised. I then offer an account of where the UK ethics review system is now and suggest three steps which could improve social science ethics review in the UK and move it in a perhaps more desirable direction.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Case against Ethics Review in the Social SciencesResearch Ethics, 2011
- Two Models of Social Science Research Ethics ReviewResearch Ethics, 2010
- Research Ethics Review and the Sociological Research RelationshipSociology, 2008
- Research ethics paperwork: what is the plot we seem to have lost?BMJ, 2004
- Ethics review roulette: what can we learn?BMJ, 2004
- Ethics and Clinical ResearchNew England Journal of Medicine, 1966