Predicting Environmental Violations: A Cross‐Method Framework Integrating Parametric and Non‐Parametric Approaches
Open Access
- 13 August 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Business Strategy and the Environment
Abstract
Prior research has mostly relied on linear and parametric models while explaining environmental non‐compliance, but they have a limited capacity to capture non‐linear and asymmetric effects of elements affecting firms' environmental compliance. We integrate a random effects logit model with advanced machine learning methods on a longitudinal firm‐year panel dataset of US publicly traded firms from 2000 to 2024 in order to address this gap. After comparing the random effects logit model estimates with XGBoost metrics and SHAP mean values, we find that firms' prior environmental compliance behaviour is a major predictor of future environmental penalty violations. The random effects logit model confirms the cumulative penalty count as a significant positive predictor, while XGBoost assigns it the highest gain and SHAP importance scores. The marginal contribution of the cumulative penalty count in the SHAP analyses suggests its diminishing marginal effects, which are hard to identify using the logit model alone. Cross‐method comparison further reveals that governance and executive incentive variables are weak predictors of future environmental violations. The findings reveal the trajectory‐dependent nature of environmental non‐compliance, with enforcement outcomes strongly associated with behavioural trajectories. This study offers a methodological contribution and demonstrates the value of cross‐method triangulation in resolving inconsistencies across parametric approaches by integrating parametric analysis and machine learning methods.Keywords
Funding Information
- Princess Nourah Bint Abdulrahman University (PNURSP2026R860)
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- Highly Reliable Organisations and Sustainability Risk Management: Safety Cultures in the Nigerian Oil and Gas Supply Chain SectorBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2024
- Factors affecting consumer purchases of natural foods: Prioritizing health consciousness and environmental sustainabilityBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2024
- The impact of sustainability‐oriented dynamic capabilities on firm growth: Investigating the green supply chain management and green political capabilitiesBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2023
- The power of the CEO and environmental decouplingBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2023
- Founder CEOs and corporate environmental violations: Evidence from S&P 1500 firmsBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2021
- Past, present, and future of green product innovationBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2021
- Do financial penalties for environmental violations facilitate improvements in corporate environmental performance? An empirical investigationBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2020
- Organizational Visibility, Stakeholder Environmental Pressure and Corporate Environmental Responsiveness in ChinaBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2016
- How Do Environmental Violation Events Harm Corporate Reputation?Business Strategy and the Environment, 2014
- Environmental Performance, Environmental Risk and Risk ManagementBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2012