Moving Beyond Pseudoargumentation: Teachers’ Enactments of an Educative Science Curriculum Focused on Argumentation
- 29 March 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Science Education
- Vol. 101 (3) , 426-457
Abstract
Argumentation, a key epistemic practice in science, engages students in socially constructing knowledge claims using evidence. However, teachers need support in integrating argumentation into classroom instruction. We examined teachers’ enactments of an educative science curriculum and their curricular decision making for argumentation. Ten middle school teachers enacted lessons that focused on both the structure of an argument and argumentation as a dialogic process. For each teacher, we analyzed videotapes of two lessons and follow‐up interviews. Across the teachers, we observed a wide range in teachers’ enactments. In some instances, teachers’ instructional practices aligned with the underlying epistemic goals, while in other cases the structural aspects were oversimplified and discourse norms followed more traditional teacher‐led patterns. To support classroom instruction to move beyond pseudoargumentation, we found three main influences on teachers’ curricular decision making in classes with higher quality argumentation: (1) teachers’ understanding of argumentation as an epistemic practice (rather than surface level features), (2) teachers as critically reflective curriculum users, and (3) teachers problematizing their prior teaching experiences. As a field, we need to think critically about how to design teacher education experiences to discourage the relabeling of teaching with reform‐oriented terms, such as argumentation, and instead support instructional transformation.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation (DRL‐1119584)
- Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Challenges and Opportunities for Language Learning in the Context of the CCSS and the NGSSJournal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 2013
- Science teachers and scientific argumentation: Trends in views and practiceJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2012
- The impact of an integrated approach to science and literacy in elementary school classroomsJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2012
- Argumentation in the Teaching of Science2011
- An analysis of the supports and constraints for scientific discussion in high school project‐based scienceScience Education, 2009
- Scientific discourse in three urban classrooms: The role of the teacher in engaging high school students in argumentationScience Education, 2009
- Urban elementary school teachers' knowledge and practices in teaching science to English language learnersScience Education, 2007
- What Do New Views of Knowledge and Thinking Have to Say About Research on Teacher Learning?Educational Researcher, 2000
- Reform by the Book: What Is—or Might Be—the Role of Curriculum Materials in Teacher Learning and Instructional Reform?Educational Researcher, 1996
- A Revolution in One Classroom: The Case of Mrs. OublierEducational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 1990