Actionable knowledge for agroecological transformation: a critical realist analysis of co-innovation in a transdisciplinary project
Open Access
- 7 July 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Sustainability Science
- p. 1-22
Abstract
Transdisciplinarity and the production of actionable knowledge with and for societal actors is a central feature of sustainability science. Yet questions remain about whether such efforts genuinely challenge the structural roots of unsustainability or inadvertently reinforce them in pursuit of proximate impacts. This paper responds to calls for more critical monitoring and evaluation by evaluating a transdisciplinary Horizon Europe project, Agroecology-TRANSECT. We employ a critical realist approach to analyze qualitative data from project work with 11 territorially-rooted European networks focused on agroecological transition (called ‘innovation hubs’(IHs). This analysis was developed as a part of the project’s co-innovation approach, with iterative reflection and validation embedded throughout the research process. Our analysis sought to explain how observed actionable knowledge outcomes came about (or did not) by examining multi-level contextual factors. Societal effects were assessed using a conforming-transforming distinction informed by political agroecology. We found that the project’s co-innovation approach has resulted in many instances of actionable knowledge production among IHs, including new conceptual and strategic developments, and providing legitimacy and resources for instrumental gains like policy change. While the project served to amplify the agency of IHs, the extent to which this resulted in transformative societal effects varied. Effects were largely shaped by the IHs’ pre-existing strategic orientation (i.e. whether they already worked to challenge, alter, or replace dominant institutional structures and reconfigure their power relations). For some IHs, structural constraints – namely, market dependency, social acceleration, and state mediation of capital accumulation – limited the extent to which their network could generate transformative effects. We conclude that co-innovation’s complex-adaptive systems approach should widen its scope of system boundaries, integrating social structural analysis to reveal root causes of blockages and enhance agential effectiveness. For actionable knowledge to achieve societal effects that are both proximate and transformative, transdisciplinary research should prioritize involvement of partners with pre-existing transformative strategies, and devote creative focus to building enabling societal contexts.Keywords
Funding Information
- HORIZON EUROPE Framework Programme (101060816)
- Swiss State Secretariat for Education, Research and Innovation (Swiss State Secretariat for Education, Research and Innovation (SERI))
- Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (JDC2022-050217-I)
- European Next Generation Programme (European Next Generation Programme)
This publication has 106 references indexed in Scilit:
- Academic Times2025
- Confronting the Projectification of Transdisciplinarity for Transformation2024
- Transdisciplinarity for Transformation2024
- Transdisciplinary transformative change: an analysis of some best practices and barriers, and the potential of critical social science in getting us thereBiodiversity and Conservation, 2023
- An essay on ready‐ing: Tending the prelude to changeSystems Research and Behavioral Science, 2022
- Policy implications of willingness to pay for sustainable development of a world agricultural heritage site: The role of stakeholders' sustainable intelligence, support, and behavioral intentionSustainable Development, 2021
- Agroecology Now!2021
- Evaluation and monitoring of transdisciplinary collaborationsThe Journal of Technology Transfer, 2017
- Stakeholder participation in agricultural research projects: a conceptual framework for reflection and decision-makingAgriculture and Human Values, 2010
- The Emergence of Transdisciplinarity as a Form of Research2007