Estimating Intra-Party Preferences: Comparing Speeches to Votes
Open Access
- 21 December 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Political Science Research and Methods
- Vol. 5 (2) , 379-396
Abstract
Well-established methods exist for measuring party positions, but reliable means for estimating intra-party preferences remain underdeveloped. While most efforts focus on estimating the ideal points of individual legislators based on inductive scaling of roll call votes, this data suffers from two problems: selection bias due to unrecorded votes and strong party discipline, which tends to make voting a strategic rather than a sincere indication of preferences. By contrast, legislative speeches are relatively unconstrained, as party leaders are less likely to punish MPs for speaking freely as long as they vote with the party line. Yet, the differences between roll call estimations and text scalings remain essentially unexplored, despite the growing application of statistical analysis of textual data to measure policy preferences. Our paper addresses this lacuna by exploiting a rich feature of the Swiss legislature: on most bills, legislators both vote and speak many times. Using this data, we compare text-based scaling of ideal points to vote-based scaling from a crucial piece of energy legislation. Our findings confirm that text scalings reveal larger intra-party differences than roll calls. Using regression models, we further explain the differences between roll call and text scalings by attributing differences to constituency-level preferences for energy policy.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Validating Estimates of Latent Traits from Textual Data Using Human Judgment as a BenchmarkPolitical Analysis, 2013
- Institutional Foundations of Legislative SpeechAmerican Journal of Political Science, 2012
- Position Taking in European Parliament SpeechesBritish Journal of Political Science, 2009
- Legislative Voting Behavior, Seen and Unseen: A Theory of Roll‐Call Vote SelectionLegislative Studies Quarterly, 2008
- Understanding WordscoresPolitical Analysis, 2008
- Left—Right Positions of Political Parties in SwitzerlandParty Politics, 2007
- Competing Principals, Political Institutions, and Party Unity in Legislative VotingAmerican Journal of Political Science, 2007
- Off the Record: Unrecorded Legislative Votes, Selection Bias and Roll-Call Vote AnalysisBritish Journal of Political Science, 2006
- The Statistical Analysis of Roll Call DataAmerican Political Science Review, 2004
- Electoral Institutions and Legislative Behavior: Explaining Voting Defection in the European ParliamentWorld Politics, 2004