Replication without repeating ourselves: Addressing the replication crisis in operations and supply chain management research
- 16 September 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Operations Management
- Vol. 67 (1) , 105-115
Abstract
Operations and supply chain management (OSCM) scholars have generally not engaged in the robust discourse over the extent and implications of science's replication crisis, perhaps because replication studies remain exceedingly rare in the discipline. In this manuscript, I encourage more replications. However, I also assume that such studies will remain rare. Therefore, it is argued that the replication crisis in OSCM can be partially addressed by conducting theory testing and refining research in a more systematic fashion that acknowledges researchers' and journals' incentives to publish new knowledge, while also efficiently helping to ensure that the foundations of that new knowledge are generalizable and not based on idiosyncratic, spurious, or questionable findings. Hence, I focus on ways to conduct a replication within a larger theory testing or refining study in a manner that makes it possible to explain the results, even if they differ from past research. This is achieved via enhanced transparency, designing research to include tests of nomological validity and account for the possibility that the results will not replicate, and more careful consideration of controls. The payoff from this investment in designing replication logic into theory testing and refining research would be that in the course of conducting normal science, we would be able to make much stronger claims about the veracity of our theories, facts, and predictions.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Designing research with in-built differentiated replicationJournal of Business Research, 2013
- Does Quality Still Pay? A Reexamination of the Relationship Between Effective Quality Management and Firm PerformanceProduction and Operations Management, 2012
- The Illusion of Statistical ControlOrganizational Research Methods, 2011
- IS THE SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT FILE DRAWER EMPTY?Journal of Supply Chain Management, 2011
- Behavior in operations management: Assessing recent findings and revisiting old assumptionsJournal of Operations Management, 2006
- The Usefulness of Measuring Disruptiveness of Innovations Ex Post in Making Ex Ante Predictions*Journal of Product Innovation Management, 2005
- Construct measurement in strategic management research: illusion or reality?Strategic Management Journal, 2004
- HELPING AND VOICE EXTRA-ROLE BEHAVIORS: EVIDENCE OF CONSTRUCT AND PREDICTIVE VALIDITY.Academy of Management Journal, 1998
- Does Implementing an Effective TQM Program Actually Improve Operating Performance? Empirical Evidence from Firms That Have Won Quality AwardsManagement Science, 1997
- MAKING FAST STRATEGIC DECISIONS IN HIGH-VELOCITY ENVIRONMENTS.Academy of Management Journal, 1989