Resolving future fire management conflicts using multicriteria decision making
- 2 November 2015
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 30 (1) , 196-205
Abstract
Management strategies to reduce the risks to human life and property from wildfire commonly involve burning native vegetation. However, planned burning can conflict with other societal objectives such as human health and biodiversity conservation. These conflicts are likely to intensify as fire regimes change under future climates and as growing human populations encroach farther into fire‐prone ecosystems. Decisions about managing fire risks are therefore complex and warrant more sophisticated approaches than are typically used. We applied a multicriteria decision making approach (MCDA) with the potential to improve fire management outcomes to the case of a highly populated, biodiverse, and flammable wildland–urban interface. We considered the effects of 22 planned burning options on 8 objectives: house protection, maximizing water quality, minimizing carbon emissions and impacts on human health, and minimizing declines of 5 distinct species types. The MCDA identified a small number of management options (burning forest adjacent to houses) that performed well for most objectives, but not for one species type (arboreal mammal) or for water quality. Although MCDA made the conflict between objectives explicit, resolution of the problem depended on the weighting assigned to each objective. Additive weighting of criteria traded off the arboreal mammal and water quality objectives for other objectives. Multiplicative weighting identified scenarios that avoided poor outcomes for any objective, which is important for avoiding potentially irreversible biodiversity losses. To distinguish reliably among management options, future work should focus on reducing uncertainty in outcomes across a range of objectives. Considering management actions that have more predictable outcomes than landscape fuel management will be important. We found that, where data were adequate, an MCDA can support decision making in the complex and often conflicted area of fire management.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Integrating Land Cover Modeling and Adaptive Management to Conserve Endangered Species and Reduce Catastrophic Fire RiskLand, 2014
- Fire Management, Managed Relocation, and Land Conservation Options for Long‐Lived Obligate Seeding Plants under Global Changes in Climate, Urbanization, and Fire RegimeConservation Biology, 2014
- How risk management can prevent future wildfire disasters in the wildland-urban interfaceProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2013
- Potential Erosion from Bladed Firelines in the Appalachian Region Estimated with USLE-Forest and WEPP ModelsSouthern Journal of Applied Forestry, 2013
- Wildfires, fuel treatment and risk mitigation in Australian eucalypt forests: Insights from landscape-scale simulationJournal of Environmental Management, 2012
- Modelling the potential for prescribed burning to mitigate carbon emissions from wildfires in fire-prone forests of AustraliaInternational Journal of Wildland Fire, 2012
- A comparison of landscape fuel treatment strategies to mitigate wildland fire risk in the urban interface and preserve old forest structureForest Ecology and Management, 2010
- Effects of weather, fuel and terrain on fire severity in topographically diverse landscapes of south-eastern AustraliaLandscape Ecology, 2009
- Relative importance of fuel management, ignition management and weather for area burned: evidence from five landscape–fire–succession modelsInternational Journal of Wildland Fire, 2009
- Cultural Inertia and Uniformity in OrganizationsThe Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, 2006