Experts, Experts Everywhere! Survey Experimental Evidence on How Involving Expertise Affects Decision-Making Legitimacy
Open Access
- 3 June 2026
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Studies
Abstract
Science and expertise are frequently invoked to legitimize policy decisions. However, while prior research suggests broad support for expert-led governance, it often overlooks how citizens differentiate between types of experts and how political beliefs shape these perceptions. This study examines how institutional affiliations of experts—universities, government, and think tanks—influence citizens’ perceptions of legitimacy in political decision-making. Drawing on two pre-registered factorial survey experiments embedded in a survey from Finland (N = 2546), we investigate (1) differences in how actors affect decision-making legitimacy, and (2) how these effects differ depending on the type of issue, outcome favourability and issue salience. Our results show that proposals involving university researchers frequently gain legitimacy, but the exact effects hinge on the type of issue, outcome favourability, and salience. These findings contribute to a more nuanced understanding of how citizens perceive the role of expertise in democratic governance.Keywords
Funding Information
- Varsinais-Suomen Rahasto (00242676)
- Koneen Säätiö (202409118)
This publication has 75 references indexed in Scilit:
- Who Cares? Issue Salience as a Key Explanation for Heterogeneity in Citizens’ Approaches to Political TrustSocial Indicators Research, 2023
- The Lure of Technocrats: A Conjoint Experiment on Preferences for Technocratic Ministers in Six European CountriesPolitical Behavior, 2023
- Do Citizens Tolerate Antidemocratic Statements?Electoral Studies, 2023
- Do technocrats boost the acceptance of policy proposals among the citizenry? Evidence from a survey experiment in ItalyElectoral Studies, 2022
- Do politicians’ answers to voting advice applications reflect their sincere beliefs? Comparing publicly and confidentially stated ideological positions in a candidate-centred electoral contextElectoral Studies, 2022
- How different are cultural and economic ideology?Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences, 2020
- What to Think About Think Tanks: Towards a Conceptual Framework of Strategic Think Tank BehaviourInternational Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society, 2018
- An experiment testing six formats of 101-point rating scalesComputers in Human Behavior, 2016
- The political use of knowledge in the policy processPolicy Sciences, 2015
- Attitude importance and attitude changeJournal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1988