A comparison of four different approaches to measuring health utility in depressed patients
Open Access
- 1 January 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Health and Quality of Life Outcomes
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-10
Abstract
A variety of instruments are used to measure health related quality of life. Few data exist on the performance and agreement of different instruments in a depressed population. The aim of this study was to investigate agreement between, and suitability of, the EQ-5D-3L, EQ-5D Visual Analogue Scale (EQ-5D VAS), SF-6D and SF-12 new algorithm for measuring health utility in depressed patients. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and Bland and Altman approaches were used to assess agreement. Instrument sensitivity was analysed by: (1) plotting utility scores for the instruments against one another; (2) correlating utility scores and depressive symptoms (Beck Depression Inventory (BDI)); and (3) using Tukey’s procedure. Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) analysis assessed instrument responsiveness to change. Acceptability was assessed by comparing instrument completion rates. The overall ICC was 0.57. Bland and Altman plots showed wide limits of agreement for each pair wise comparison, except between the SF-6D and SF-12 new algorithm. Plots of utility scores displayed ’ceiling effects’ in the EQ-5D-3L index and ’floor effects’ in the SF-6D and SF-12 new algorithm. All instruments showed a negative monotonic relationship with BDI, but the EQ-5D-3L index and EQ-5D VAS could not differentiate between depression severity sub-groups. The SF-based instruments were better able to detect changes in health state over time. There was no difference in completion rates of the four instruments. There was a lack of agreement between utility scores generated by the different instruments. According to the criteria of sensitivity, responsiveness and acceptability that we applied, the SF-6D and SF-12 may be more suitable for the measurement of health related utility in a depressed population than the EQ-5D-3L, which is the instrument currently recommended by NICE.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Baseline comparison of three health utility measures and the feeling thermometer among participants in the action to control cardiovascular risk in diabetes trialCardiovascular Diabetology, 2012
- Development and preliminary testing of the new five-level version of EQ-5D (EQ-5D-5L)Quality of Life Research, 2011
- Projections of Global Mortality and Burden of Disease from 2002 to 2030PLOS Medicine, 2006
- Is there a case for using visual analogue scale valuations in cost‐utility analysis?Health Economics, 2006
- A comparison of the EQ‐5D and SF‐6D across seven patient groupsHealth Economics, 2004
- To what extent do people prefer health states with higher values? A note on evidence from the EQ‐5D valuation setHealth Economics, 2003
- A comparative review of four preference-weighted measures of health-related quality of lifeJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2003
- EQ-SD: a measure of health status from the EuroQol GroupAnnals of Medicine, 2001
- Methods for assessing responsivenessJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2000
- STATISTICAL METHODS FOR ASSESSING AGREEMENT BETWEEN TWO METHODS OF CLINICAL MEASUREMENTThe Lancet, 1986