Highly Elevated Scores on the Beck Depression Inventory–Second Edition as an Indicator of Noncredible Symptom Report
Author:
- 29 December 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Assessment
- Vol. 32 (8) , 1226-1234
Abstract
Some recent studies have revived the approach of investigating extreme levels of self-reported depressive symptoms as indicative of gross exaggeration. While scores above 40 on the Beck Depression Inventory–Second Edition (BDI-II) were discussed as indicating exaggerated symptom claims, different cut scores for identifying noncredible responding are now being discussed. A consecutive sample of 242 patients referred for forensic psychological assessment (mean age: 46.0 years, 47.7% women) with full data sets on the BDI-II and the Structured Inventory of Malingered Symptomatology (SIMS) were assessed. Of all patients, 13.2% scored above 40 and BDI-II scores correlated with SIMS total scores at .62. For different SIMS cutoffs (>14, >16, >19, >23) used as criterion standard, optimal cut scores for the BDI-II were computed. When specificity was set at a minimum of 90%, sensitivity estimates were below 50% for all four SIMS levels. Extreme scores on the BDI-II should raise concern about the credibility of self-reported depressive symptom load. Diagnosis as well as severity estimates should not be based primarily on self-report instruments. To avoid significant risks of bias, the development of reliable cut scores for BDI-II elevations should be based on more studies with samples from diverse contexts.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Beck Depression Inventory—Second Edition as a Symptom Validity Test: Importing European Cutoffs to the USAPsychological Injury and Law, 2024
- Symptom validity indices in the Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist for DSM‐5Journal of Traumatic Stress, 2023
- First Do No Harm: Ethical Issues in Pathologizing Normal Variations in Behavior and FunctioningPsychological Injury and Law, 2022
- Structured Inventory of Malingered Symptomatology: a Psychometric ReviewPsychological Injury and Law, 2021
- Motor Reaction Times as an Embedded Measure of Performance Validity: a Study with a Sample of Austrian Early Retirement ClaimantsPsychological Injury and Law, 2021
- The Self-Report Symptom Inventory (SRSI): a New Instrument for the Assessment of Distorted Symptom EndorsementPsychological Injury and Law, 2016
- The Pervasive Influence of Effort on Neuropsychological TestsPhysical Medicine and Rehabilitation Clinics of North America, 2007
- The Use of the MMPI-2 Infrequency–Psychopathology Scale in the Assessment of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder in Male VeteransJournal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment, 2004
- "Strukturierter Fragebogen Simulierter Symptome"Der Nervenarzt, 2003
- Faking a profile: can naive subjects simulate whiplash responses?Pain, 1996