Making the right choices: ethical judgments among educational leaders
Authors:
- 5 July 2011
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Educational Administration
- Vol. 49 (4) , 396-413
Abstract
Purpose – Scholars have adopted a multiple ethical paradigms approach in an attempt to better understand the bases upon which everyday ethical dilemmas are resolved by educational leaders. The aim of this study is to examine the ethical considerations in ethical judgments of aspiring principals. Design/methodology/approach – To examine the ethical considerations involved in school leadership decision making, a specially designed ethical perspective instrument was developed that draws on the multiple ethical paradigms. This exploratory instrument was pre-tested for validity and reliability among school principals and students of educational administration. The research sample consisted of 52 participants in principal training programs in Israel. Findings – Negative correlations were found between choices reflecting values of fairness and those reflecting utilitarianism and care. In addition, negative correlations were found between choices reflecting values of community and those reflecting care, critique, and profession. Critique turned out to be the value most widely adopted by educational leaders to solve ethical dilemmas, followed by care and profession. Originality/value – The common notion in the literature is that the various ethics complement one another. There is, however, little empirical work on ethical judgments of educational practitioners. The importance of this exploratory research is twofold: first, it examines the extent to which multiple ethical considerations can be taken into account simultaneously; and second, it identifies the prevailing values that come into play most often.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ethical Dilemmas of Swedish School LeadersEducational Management Administration & Leadership, 2007
- Ethical School LeadershipEducational Management Administration & Leadership, 2007
- Developing Moral Principles and Scenarios in the Light of Diversity: An Extension to the Multidimensional Ethics ScaleJournal of Business Ethics, 2006
- Ethical dilemmas: the “bread and butter” of educational leaders' livesJournal of Educational Administration, 2006
- A Review of The Empirical Ethical Decision-Making Literature: 1996–2003Journal of Business Ethics, 2005
- Codes, Values and Justifications in the Ethical Decision-Making ProcessJournal of Business Ethics, 2005
- The 'right' decision? Towards an understanding of ethical dilemmas for school leadersWestminster Studies in Education, 2003
- Becoming a Principal: Role Conception, Initial Socialization, Role-Identity Transformation, Purposeful EngagementEducational Administration Quarterly, 2003
- Implementing Reforms in a Centralised Education System: the case of Israeli educationOxford Review of Education, 1994
- Educational Policy‐making and Planning in a Small Centralised DemocracyComparative Education, 1986