In this study, novices and experts used the same metaphors to understand and solve problems with negative numbers. However, they used them differently. Twenty-four participants (12 middle school children and 12 postsecondary adults) computed arithmetic expressions during the problem-solving task. During this task, children used metaphors more often than adults did to compute, detect and correct errors, and justify their answers. Metaphorical computations were more accurate but slower than other methods. The participants explained 6 arithmetic expressions during the understanding task. During this task, the adults used more metaphors (with fewer details) and used them more often than the children did. Compared to the median child, the median adult showed a more integrated understanding of arithmetic through multiple metaphors, mathematical rules, and transformations. These results suggest that the metaphors used by both the children and the adults are central to understanding arithmetic. Thus, these metaphors are likely candidates for theory-constitutive metaphors.