Which Laser System Is Optimal for Cystolithotripsy of Large Bladder Calculi?
Authors:
- Mohammad HajihaMHMohammad Hajiha
- Ala'A FarkouhAFAla'A Farkouh
- Akin AmasyaliAAAkin Amasyali
- Matthew I BuellMBMatthew I Buell
- Rose LeuRLRose Leu
- Jason GroeglerJGJason Groegler
- John SmithJSJohn Smith
- Arthur GoyneAGArthur Goyne
- D Daniel BaldwinDBD Daniel Baldwin
- Reihaneh MoghisiRMReihaneh Moghisi
- D Duane BaldwinDBD Duane Baldwin
- 1 November 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Endourology
- Vol. 37 (11) , 1221-1227
Abstract
Introduction and Objective: A variety of laser sources are available to treat bladder stones. The aim of this study was to compare time and cost efficiency of the thulium fiber laser (TFL) to four holmium lasers (HLs) with different powers or technologies, including MOSES™ during simulated cystolithotripsy. Materials and Methods: In a benchtop simulation of laser cystolithotripsy, 25 identical 4-cm BegoStones (calcium oxalate monohydrate consistency) were placed on a grid within a 3D-printed bladder model. Lasers were operated at maximal energy, using a 550 μm fiber. Lasers compared were as follows: 60 W TFL, 120 W HL with MOSES, and conventional 120, 100, and 30 W HLs. Five trials were performed for each laser with endpoints of laser time, total time, number of fiber strippings, and total energy. Cost-effectiveness was modeled using laser purchase price, fiber, and operating room (OR) time cost. ANOVA with Tukey's B post hoc was performed to compare outcomes. Spearman's test was used to assess correlation between laser power and procedure time. Results: The laser and total operating times were significantly different between the five systems ( p < 0.001). The 120 W HL with MOSES was the fastest with 60.9 minutes of laser and 68.3 minutes of procedure times, while the 30 W HL was the slowest with 281.2 minutes of laser and 297.5 minutes of procedure times. The 60 W TFL was faster than the 30 W HL, but slower than the higher power HLs. Higher laser power was associated with shorter procedure time ( R s = −0.98; p = 0.002). When estimating cost per procedure, the MOSES HL was the cheapest, but had the highest purchase cost. The TFL was not cost-effective for large bladder stones compared with the 100 W HL. Conclusions: When treating large bladder stones, total laser power was highly correlated with laser and procedure times and the TFL was limited by its total power. The most cost-effective laser for use will depend on the case volume.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Bladder stone management: an updateMinerva Urology and Nephrology, 2018
- Moses technology in a stone simulatorCanadian Urological Association Journal, 2017
- Use of the Moses Technology to Improve Holmium Laser Lithotripsy Outcomes: A Preclinical StudyJournal of Endourology, 2017
- Outpatient Transurethral Cystolithotripsy of Large Bladder Stones by Holmium LaserJournal of lasers in medical sciences, 2016
- Transurethral Cystolithotripsy of Large Bladder Stones by Holmium Laser as a Day Care ProcedureJournal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research, 2016
- Laser lithotripsy retropulsion varies with stone mass2013
- Correlation between the operation time using two different power settings of a Ho: YAG laser: laser power doesn’t influence lithotripsy timeBMC Research Notes, 2013
- The Management of Bladder Lithiasis in the Modern Era of EndourologyUrology, 2012
- BegoStone—a new stone phantom for shock wave lithotripsy research (L)The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 2002
- Holmium:Yttrium-aluminum-garnet laser cystolithotripsy of large bladder calculiUrology, 1997