Challenges and Best Practices in Ethical Review of Human and Organizational Factors Studies in Health Technology: a Synthesis of Testimonies
Authors:
Open Access
- 17 April 2020
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Yearbook of Medical Informatics
- Vol. 29 (01) , 058-070
Abstract
Summary: Objective: Human and Organizational Factors (HOF) studies in health technology involve human beings and thus require Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval. Yet HOF studies have specific constraints and methods that may not fit standard regulations and IRB practices. Gaining IRB approval may pose difficulties for HOF researchers. This paper aims to provide a first overview of HOF study challenges to get IRB review by exploring differences and best practices across different countries. Methods: HOF researchers were contacted by email to provide a testimony about their experience with IRB review and approval. Testimonies were thematically analyzed and synthesized to identify and discuss shared themes. Results: Researchers from seven European countries, Argentina, Canada, Australia, and the United States answered the call. Four themes emerged that indicate shared challenges in legislation, IRB inefficiencies and inconsistencies, general regulation and costs, and lack of HOF study knowledge by IRB members. We propose a model for IRB review of HOF studies based on best practices. Conclusion: International criteria are needed that define low and high-risk HOF studies, to allow identification of studies that can undergo an expedited (or exempted) process from those that need full IRB review. Enhancing IRB processes in such a way would be beneficial to the conduct of HOF studies. Greater knowledge and promotion of HOF methods and evidence-based HOF study designs may support the evolving discipline. Based on these insights, training and guidance to IRB members may be developed to support them in ensuring that appropriate ethical issues for HOF studies are considered.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Variability in Institutional Board Review for a Multisite Assessment of Resident ProfessionalismJournal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics, 2019
- French legal approach to clinical researchAnaesthesia Critical Care & Pain Medicine, 2018
- Multi‐centre ethics and research governance review can impede non‐interventional clinical researchInternal Medicine Journal, 2018
- AMIA’s code of professional and ethical conduct 2018Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 2018
- Evaluation of Hospital-Wide Computerised Decision Support in an Intensive Care Unit: An Observational StudyAnaesthesia and Intensive Care, 2016
- From Usability Engineering to Evidence-based Usability in Health IT.2016
- Optimising computerised alerts within electronic medication management systems: A synthesis of four years of research.2014
- Junior doctors’ prescribing work after-hours and the impact of computerized decision supportInternational Journal of Medical Informatics, 2013
- The influence of computerized decision support on prescribing during ward-rounds: are the decision-makers targeted?Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 2011
- Quality Improvement and Ethical OversightAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2007