Abstract
This paper deals with the influence of the medium access control (MAC) protocol in the performance of the communication channels used in the SCADA systems (Supervisory Control And Data Acquisition). Three types of MAC protocols are presented and analyzed: Polling, CSMA/CD (Carrier Sense Multiple Access with Collision Detection), and Token Bus. The simulation of each one of these protocols allows us to quantify its performance and establish certain criteria to be able to compare them. As a result of the analysis, the use of a MAC protocol is proposed for SCADA systems. I. INTRODUCTION. The use of SCADA system for operating power networks is supported by a distributed architecture, with dozens or hundreds of computers, called Remote Terminal Units (RTUs). These RTUs communicate with a control center, transmitting the measures and the state of the power network, accepting the commands which have to be carried out within the system. Taking into account the large amount of equipment and their geographical dispersion the communication with the control center usually use multiplexed lines where narrowband channels are available. For this reason, the lines used between the center and each RTU are of low speed, running typically at 600 or 1200 bps (bits per second). On the other hand, in order to lower the total number of required channels, several RTUs are usually connected to each line, sharing the channel's resources. This multipoint configuration (fig. 1) means that the communication protocol which is being used, includes procedures which permits the coordination of the access to the physical medium which is being used. These procedures are called Medium Access Control (MAC), and the corresponding protocol is called a MAC protocol. There are a large number of protocols used in SCADA systems. Many of them have been developed by the system manufacturers, some by the users, and only a small percentage of them correspond to the standardizing efforts. However, there is a general trend towards considering the protocols as a seven layer structure following the OSI model (1) where, in the case of power network protocols, one or more of these layers are empty. In the figure 2, the seven layer OSI model is presented and compared to the EPA model (Enhanced Protocol Architecture) specifically proposed by the IEC (International Electrotechnical Commission) (2) for the telecontrol of power networks. In both approaches, the control procedures for the Medium Access Control are in the lower sublayer of the Data Link Level (layer 2).

This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit: