Sustainability Assessment of Industrialised and Conventional Renovation Pathways for Public Housing: Operational and Embodied Carbon Trade-Offs in a Stock-Level Study in the Comunitat Valenciana (Spain)
Open Access
- 29 April 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 18 (9) , 4379
Abstract
Sustainable renovation of existing residential building stocks is essential to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, improve energy performance, and support long-term climate-neutral housing strategies. However, decisions based only on operational indicators may overlook important product-stage embodied impacts, especially in highly integrated renovation solutions. This study evaluates how alternative renovation pathways for a public residential building portfolio in the Comunitat Valenciana (Spain) perform from a stock-level sustainability perspective, comparing five INFINITE industrialised retrofit kits (Kit 1–Kit 5) with five paired conventional renovation scenarios (S1–S5). A bottom-up building stock modelling workflow is applied, combining building-energy simulation to quantify operational performance and emissions (B6) with a screening life-cycle assessment of product-stage embodied carbon reported as GWP (A1–A3). To relate upfront and in-use impacts, the study computes carbon payback, cumulative emissions avoided, and a horizon-based partial life-cycle climate indicator, PLC(H), assessed for 2030, 2035, and 2050. The results show a clear sustainability trade-off: renovation packages that sharply reduce operational emissions often require higher upfront embodied carbon, shifting net climate benefits towards longer time horizons. Low-embodied options provide earlier benefits, with Kit 1 reducing PLC(H) by 15.5% by 2030, whereas deeper decarbonisation packages achieve stronger long-term outcomes, with S5 reducing PLC(H) by 70.7% by 2050. A bounded electricity-decarbonisation sensitivity further shows that these long-horizon rankings are affected by lower grid-emission factors, particularly for highly electrified pathways, although the strongest 2050 pathways remain robust across the tested cases. Overall, the findings show that sustainable stock-level renovation planning should jointly consider operational and embodied carbon, carbon payback, and milestone-based cumulative impacts in order to support balanced portfolio sequencing between broadly deployable fast-payback measures and selective deep retrofits.Keywords
Funding Information
- EU Horizon 2020 INFINITE project (958397)
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Integrating energy, cost, and carbon assessments into building portfolio management: A case studyEnergy and Buildings, 2025
- Predicting Energy and Emissions in Residential Building Stocks: National UBEM with Energy Performance Certificates and Artificial IntelligenceApplied Sciences, 2025
- Building renovations and life cycle assessment - A scoping literature reviewRenewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2024
- Assessing life cycle sustainability of building renovation and reconstruction: A comprehensive review of case studies and methodsBuilding and Environment, 2024
- Building renovation plan - introducing energy and cost into the managerial perspectives: A case studyEnergy and Buildings, 2024
- Building energy simulation and its application for building performance optimization: A review of methods, tools, and case studiesAdvances in Applied Energy, 2023
- Low-carbon retrofits in social housing: Energy efficiency, multidimensional energy poverty, and domestic comfort strategies in southern EuropeEnergy Research & Social Science, 2022
- Embodied GHG emissions of buildings – The hidden challenge for effective climate change mitigationApplied Energy, 2020
- Estimating the energy-saving potential in national building stocks – A methodology reviewRenewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2018
- Strategy for the energy renovation of the housing stock in Comunitat Valenciana (Spain)Energy and Buildings, 2016