We describe Rosendolops primigenium gen. et sp. nov (Mammalia, Marsupialia, Polydolopimorphia), based on isolated upper molars found in early Eocene (Casamayoran Age) beds from the cliffs south of Lake Colhue-Huapi (Province of Chubut, Argentina). The molar pattern shown by Rosendolops primigenium is clearly anticipatory of the characteristic polydolopimorphian (i.e., Prepidolopidae, Bonapartheriidae, and Polydolopidae) pattern, although the synapomorphies typical of the group are already present. Reigia punae and the Protodidelphidae (sensu Marshall, Case and Woodburne, 1990) are excluded from the Polydolopimorphia as they lack these synapomorphies. The morphotype represented by Rosendolops primigenium sheds new light on the possible progressive modifications that enabled the establishment of the molar pattern in South American “pseudodiprotodont” marsupials.