Liver Transplant Recipient Selection: MELD vs. Clinical Judgment
Authors:
- 1 June 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Liver Transplantation
- Vol. 11 (6) , 621-626
Abstract
Minimization of death while waiting for liver transplantation involves accurate prioritization according to clinical status and appropriate allocation of donor livers. Clinical judgment in the Liver Transplant Unit Victoria (LTUV) was compared with Model for End-Stage Liver Disease (MELD) in a retrospective analysis of the LTUV database over the 2-year period August 1, 2002, through July 31, 2004. A total of 1,118 prioritization decisions occurred. Decisions were concordant in 758 (68%), comparing priorities assigned by clinical judgment with those assigned by MELD, P < 0.01. A total of 263 allocation decisions occurred. Decisions were concordant in 190 (72%) and 203 (77%) of the cases, comparing donor liver allocation with prioritization by MELD and clinical judgment, respectively. Of the 52 patients allocated a liver, only 23 would have been allocated on the basis of MELD while 29 had been prioritized on the waiting list in the week prior to transplantation. A total of 10 patients died on the waiting list in the 2-year period (annual adult waiting list mortality is 9.3%). Patients who subsequently died waiting were 3 times as likely to be prioritized by MELD as clinical judgment (29% vs. 9%, respectively). One half (3 of 6) of the patients who could have received a donor liver but who died waiting would have been allocated the organ on the basis of MELD. In conclusion, an allocation process based on MELD rather than clinical judgment would significantly alter organ allocation in Australia and may reduce waiting list mortality.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- MELD Scores of Liver Transplant Recipients According to Size of Waiting ListJAMA, 2004
- Results of the first year of the new liver allocation planLiver Transplantation, 2004
- Outcome of liver transplantation for patients infected by hepatitis C, including those infected by genotype 4Liver Transplantation, 2003
- A Model to Predict Severe Hcv–Related Disease Following Liver TransplantationHepatology, 2003
- Liver transplantation for HCV-associated liver cirrhosis: Predictors of outcomes in a population with significant genotype 3 and 4 distributionLiver Transplantation, 2003
- The new liver allocation system: Moving toward evidence-based transplantation policyLiver Transplantation, 2002
- Contribution of donor age to the recent decrease in patient survival among HCV-infected liver transplant recipientsHepatology, 2002
- Impact of cytomegalovirus infection, year of transplantation, and donor age on outcomes after liver transplantation for hepatitis CLiver Transplantation, 2002
- MELD and PELD: Application of survival models to liver allocationLiver Transplantation, 2001
- A model to predict poor survival in patients undergoing transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shuntsHepatology, 2000