Can you standardise transformation? Reflections on the transformative potential of benchmarking as a mode of governance
- 21 February 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Local Environment
- Vol. 28 (7) , 918-933
Abstract
This paper is a collaborative effort between academic researchers and practitioners to consider the conditions under which global benchmarking may be used as a tool for supporting urban transformation. Reflecting on WWF’s One Planet City Challenge and UN-Habitat’s Guiding Principles for City Climate Action Planning, the paper suggests that the practice of global benchmarking can be transformative through encouraging organisational learning and reflection, building relationships between cities and global and trans-local organisations, and governing for structurally transformative qualities. However, the practice of benchmarking is not without potential tensions: they may reify existing practices rather than reforming them, be less usable for or accessible to cities in lower income countries, and may neglect issues of climate justice, which are not easily reduced to comparative measures of success or failure. This suggests that a wholesale reliance on benchmarking as a mode of governing climate change might risk marginalising certain issues and amplifying others. We conclude by recommending improved material and technical support for urban data collection and suggest that benchmarking should be combined with a broader suite of performance indicators and reflective practices in order to support urban transformation.Keywords
Funding Information
- Durham University
- Horizon 2020 (No. 730243)
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Measuring and comparing local sustainable development through common indicators: Constraints and achievements in practiceCities, 2014
- Benchmarking sustainability in cities: The role of indicators and future scenariosGlobal Environmental Change, 2012
- Apocalypse Forever?Theory, Culture & Society, 2010
- Political power beyond the State: problematics of governmentThe British Journal of Sociology, 2010
- Cities, Europeanization and Multi‐level Governance: Governing Climate Change through Transnational Municipal Networks*JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 2009
- Urban Sustainability: Learning from Best Practice?Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 2006
- City benchmarking: A methodological proposal referring specifically to GranadaCities, 2005
- Do Indicators Help Create Sustainable Communities?Local Environment, 2003
- Urban Sustainability ReportingJournal of the American Planning Association, 1996
- A PUBLIC MANAGEMENT FOR ALL SEASONS?Public Administration, 1991