The Quality of Practice Guidelines for Melanoma: A Methodologic Appraisal with the AGREE II and AGREE-REX Instruments
Authors:
Open Access
Abstract
Multiple guidelines on cutaneous melanoma (CM) are available from several consortia and countries. To provide up-to-date guidance in the rapidly changing field of melanoma treatment, guideline developers have to provide regular updates without compromises of quality. We performed a systematic search in guideline databases, Medline and Embase to identify guidelines on CM. The methodological quality of the identified guidelines was independently assessed by five reviewers using the instruments “Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation” (AGREE II) and “Recommendation EXcellence” (AGREE-REX). We performed descriptive analysis, explored subgroup differences using the Kruskal–Wallis (H) test and examined the relationship between distinct domains and items of the instruments with Spearman’s correlation. Six guidelines by consortia from Australia, France, Germany, Scotland, Spain and the United States of America were included. The German guideline fulfilled 71%–98% of criteria in AGREE II and 78%–96% for AGREE-REX, obtaining the highest scores. Deficiencies in the domains of “applicability” and “values and preferences” were observed in all guidelines. The German and Spanish guidelines significantly differed from each other in most of the domains. The domains “applicability” and “values and preferences” were identified as methodological weaknesses requiring careful revision and improvement in the future.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Chinese Guidelines on the Diagnosis and Treatment of Melanoma (2015 Edition)Chinese Clinical Oncology, 2016
- Recommendations for kidney disease guideline updating: a report by the KDIGO Methods CommitteeKidney International, 2016
- Brazilian guidelines for diagnosis, treatment and follow-up of primary cutaneous melanoma - Part IIAnais Brasileiros de Dermatologia, 2016
- Guidelines of the Brazilian Dermatology Society for diagnosis, treatment and follow up of primary cutaneous melanoma - Part IAnais Brasileiros de Dermatologia, 2015
- Cutaneous melanoma: ESMO Clinical Practice Guidelines for diagnosis, treatment and follow-upAnnals of Oncology, 2015
- The methodological quality assessment tools for preclinical and clinical studies, systematic review and meta‐analysis, and clinical practice guideline: a systematic reviewJournal of Evidence-Based Medicine, 2015
- Appraising a tool for guideline appraisal (the AGREE II instrument)Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2010
- Versioning computer-interpretable guidelines: Semi-automatic modeling of ‘Living Guidelines’ using an information extraction methodArtificial Intelligence in Medicine, 2009
- A systematic review of appraisal tools for clinical practice guidelines: multiple similarities and one common deficitInternational Journal for Quality in Health Care, 2005
- Valoración de escalas y criterios para la evaluación de guías de práctica clínicaRevista Espanola de Salud Publica, 2004