Contamination of the residential recycling waste stream has been increasing in many jurisdictions in Canada. It is a major problem for those responsible for marketing recyclables and for those working to keep recyclables out of landfills. In the province of Ontario, the case study for this chapter, households are being urged to recycle right, where recycle right means recycling without contaminating the recycling stream. Using the concept of consumption work, we highlight the inextricability of the individual resident in the recycling system and the extent to which other stakeholders are dependent on residents to provide a clean supply of recyclables. The chapter’s main research question is: what challenges do stakeholders perceive for recycling right in Ontario? The findings are based on interviews with 24 recycling and packaging stakeholders. Participants identified several reasons for contamination, including geographic variability of accepted materials, type of collection system, nonrecyclable packaging, and recycling complexity. We also explore the potential for a shift from the province’s current shared extended producer responsibility (EPR) program for recycling to full EPR to address these issues.