Reliability Reserve: A Markov Chain-Based Metric for Real-Time Operator Decision Support in Ayran Fermentation
Authors:
- Zhanagul DoumchariyevaZDZhanagul Doumchariyeva
- Jamalbek TussupovJTJamalbek Tussupov
- Madina SambetbayevaMSMadina Sambetbayeva
- Tamara ZhukabayevaTZTamara Zhukabayeva
- Madina YessenaliyevaMYMadina Yessenaliyeva
- Begzhan KalemsharivBKBegzhan Kalemshariv
- Sagi IssayevSISagi Issayev
- Munaram KhassanovaMKMunaram Khassanova
Open Access
- 3 July 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Informatics
- Vol. 13 (7) , 105
Abstract
This study presents a Markov chain-based metric called the Reliability Reserve (τ), designed to estimate the time available for operator intervention during the ayran fermentation process. This indicator can be integrated into a digital twin forecast management system. The fermentation process was obtained using a DTMC (discrete-time Markov chain) and divided into five states according to pH (S1–S5). Laboratory samples were prepared from premium-grade cow’s milk sourced from the Zher-Ana farm and divided into three experimental groups: Control (without additives), Opt1 (3% additive), and Opt2 (4% additive). A sequence of states was created for the three studied groups (Control, Opt1, and Opt2), and the transition states of the matrix were calculated. The Reliability Reserve quantifies how much time is left before the system transitions from the target state to the acidification state. For the first group, P45 was 0.200, corresponding to τ = 26.9 min. The incorporation of functional additives increased P45 to 0.250, reducing τ to 20.9 min and shortening the operator intervention window by approximately 6 min. Markov chains were constructed using 101 interpolated time points obtained from five experimental pH measurements for each group. The original pH values were recorded at 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10 h of fermentation and linearly interpolated with a step size of 0.1 h to improve temporal resolution. Model robustness was evaluated using sensitivity analysis (±0.05 pH boundary shifts) and bootstrap resampling (n = 1000, 95% confidence intervals). The concept of Reliability Reserve is a practical decision-making tool in real time. It offers an alternative to traditional reliability indicators such as MTTF and allows integration into digital twin-based control systems.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Digital Twin Framework for Bioprocess Development Using IoT Sensor Data2026
- AI-driven real-time monitoring and predictive control system for yoghurt fermentationFood Control, 2025
- Applications of artificial intelligence in the dairy Industry: From farm to product developmentComputers and Electronics in Agriculture, 2025
- Search for Influence Factors in Lactobacilli with Probiotic Properties Isolated from Traditional Kazakh FoodsProbiotics and Antimicrobial Proteins, 2024
- Metabolic regulatory network kinetic modeling with multiple isotopic tracers for iPSCsBiotechnology and Bioengineering, 2023
- A Markov-Dependent stochastic approach to modeling lactation curves in dairy cowsSmart Agricultural Technology, 2023
- Digital twin composition in smart manufacturing via Markov decision processesComputers in Industry, 2023
- Dynamic modeling of milk acidification: an empirical approachFood and Bioproducts Processing, 2021
- Kinetic Modeling of Mammalian Cell Culture Bioprocessing: The Quest to Advance BiomanufacturingBiotechnology Journal, 2017
- Continuous Time Markov Chain Models for Chemical Reaction Networks2011