A Multiple Regression Model Approach to Contrast The Performance of 2-Hydroxy-4-Methylthio Butanoic Acid and DL-Methionine Supplementation Tested in Broiler Experiments and Reported in the Literature
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 April 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Elsevier in Poultry Science
- Vol. 85 (4) , 693-705
Abstract
The purpose of this paper was to compile all available literature comparing the relative performance of 2-hydroxy-4-methylthio butanoic acid (HMTBA) with DL-methionine (DLM) in broiler chickens and using multiple regression techniques, to estimate the predicted dose responses and relative performance of the 2 Met compounds for gain and feed conversion (FC). A database was developed that contained all available broiler studies in which HMTBA and DLM were both present in the same study; weight gain was recorded; Met addition, age of birds, and duration of study were defined; and an unsupplemented control treatment was present. Sixty-two references complied with these criteria and included 100 experiments with 427 observations for HMTBA and 411 for DLM. Multiple regression analysis of the database was used to identify the experimental and dietary conditions that contributed to the gain and FC responses of each source of Met activity. All identified variables contributed similarly to each Met source prediction model and both gain and FC models described a quadratic dose response. Under the average conditions of the database, the predicted responses for gain and FC models did not significantly differ between HMTBA and DLM. However, a trend was observed (P≤0.1) for the peak gain response for HMTBA to be numerically greater than DLM, suggesting benefits of HMTBA over DLM in the region of supplementation that is commercially relevant. The experimental and nutritional conditions that contribute to the response to HTMBA and DLM were identified and are discussed in the paper. This statistical approach provided a means to summarize the results obtained from a multitude of studies conducted over the last 5 decades and has provided a meaningful estimate of the relative performance of the 2 sources of Met activity. The lack of differences between the 2 predicted models under experimental and commercial conditions supports an overall conclusion of equal performance of DLM and HTMBA when compared on an equal molar basis.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Methionine sources do not affect performance and carcass yield of broilers fed vegetable diets and aubmitted to cyclic heat stressBrazilian Journal of Poultry Science, 2005
- Use of Alimet Feed Supplement (2-Hydroxy-4-(Methylthio) Butanoic Acid, HMTBA) for Broiler ProductionThe Journal of Poultry Science, 2004
- Review of the metabolism of 2-hydroxy-4-(methylthio) butanoic acidWorld's Poultry Science Journal, 2003
- Effects of dl-methionine hydroxyanalogue (MHA) or dl-methionine (dl-Met) on N-retention in broiler chickens and pigsAnimal Feed Science and Technology, 1999
- Performance, breast meat yield and abdominal fat deposition of male broiler chickens fed diets supplemented with DL‐xnethionine or DL‐xnethionine hydroxy analogue free acidBritish Poultry Science, 1997
- Biological efficacy and absorption of DL‐methionine hydroxy analogue free acid compared to DL‐methionine in chickens as affected by heat stressBritish Poultry Science, 1995
- Responses of finishing broilers at high temperatures to dietary methionine source and supplementation levelsAustralian Journal of Agricultural Research, 1990
- Efficacité comparée pour la croissance du poussin de différentes sources de méthionineAnimal Research, 1990
- GROWTH AND CARCASS CHARACTERISTICS OF BROILERS FED SALINOMYCIN IN DIETS CONTAINING GRADED LEVELS OF METHIONINE AND ENERGYCanadian Journal of Animal Science, 1983
- Chick bio‐assay of methionine and cystineBritish Poultry Science, 1964