The impacts of REDD+ on the social-ecological resilience of community forests
Authors:
Open Access
- 19 January 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 16 (2) , 024001
Abstract
Reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation (REDD+) has emerged as an important and cost-effective climate change mitigation strategy internationally. In many localities around the world, REDD+ and related interventions have been superimposed on, and overlap with, existing decentralized institutional arrangements such as community forests. These interventions often modify local institutions through new rules and practices that comply with mostly carbon-related objectives, prompting questions about the compatibility of a top-down mechanism such as REDD+ with the decentralized approaches of community forestry. Thus, we asked: are REDD+ interventions in community forests enhancing or detracting from communities’ abilities to practice adaptive management and governance—key desired components of local social-ecological resilience and the ability of communities to respond to disturbance and global change? We conducted a systematic review of studies examining REDD+ interventions in community forests. We extracted data on 59 case studies reported on in 43 articles, stemming from 14 countries, with two thirds of the cases located in two countries alone. Our meta-analysis found that REDD+ has had mixed impacts on communities’ social-ecological resilience. Increases in network ties, connectivity across scales, and increased participation in decision making are indicators of enhanced potential for local adaptability. However, we also see that, through restrictions on local forest practices, rigidity in rules, and communities’ natural capital being locked into carbon contracts, REDD+ has limited communities’ ability to manage for uncertainty. While not representative of all existing REDD+ projects, our results suggest important implications for REDD+ policymakers and forest-reliant communities engaging in REDD+. Reconciling REDD+ goals with the need for forest communities to retain adaptive capacity will be a challenge moving forward, particularly if REDD+ compromises the ability of forest-reliant communities to respond to unexpected shocks or their ability to adapt to changing environmental or economic conditions.Keywords
This publication has 60 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Performance of REDD+: From Global Governance to Local PracticesForests, 2019
- Livelihood Implications and Perceptions of Large Scale Investment in Natural Resources for Conservation and Carbon Sequestration: Empirical Evidence from REDD+ in VietnamSustainability, 2017
- Environmental Governance for the Anthropocene? Social-Ecological Systems, Resilience, and Collaborative LearningSustainability, 2017
- When community forestry meets REDD+: has REDD+ helped address implementation barriers to participatory forest management in Tanzania?Journal of Eastern African Studies, 2017
- Comparing methods for assessing the effectiveness of subnational REDD+ initiativesEnvironmental Research Letters, 2017
- Learning from REDD+: a response to Fletcher et al.Conservation Biology, 2017
- Ten Years of REDD+: A Critical Review of the Impact of REDD+ on Forest-Dependent CommunitiesSustainability, 2016
- Implementing REDD+ at the local level: Assessing the key enablers for credible mitigation and sustainable livelihood outcomesJournal of Environmental Management, 2015
- Forest Rights: The Hard Currency of REDD+Conservation Letters, 2013
- Can REDD+ Save the Forest? The Role of Payments and TenureForests, 2012