A Comparison between Three Different Techniques Considering Quality Skills, Fatigue and Hand Pain during a Prolonged Infant Resuscitation: A Cross-Over Study with Lifeguards
Authors:
- Roberto Barcala-FurelosRBRoberto Barcala-Furelos
- Martín Barcala-FurelosMBMartín Barcala-Furelos
- Francisco Cano-NogueraFCFrancisco Cano-Noguera
- Martín Otero-AgraMOMartín Otero-Agra
- Alejandra Alonso-CalveteAAAlejandra Alonso-Calvete
- Santiago Martínez-IsasiSMSantiago Martínez-Isasi
- Silvia Aranda-GarcíaSilvia Aranda-García
- Sergio López-GarcíaSergio López-García
- Antonio Rodríguez-NúñezARAntonio Rodríguez-Núñez
Open Access
Abstract
The aim of the study was to compare the quality of CPR (Q-CPR), as well as the perceived fatigue and hand pain in a prolonged infant cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) performed by lifeguards using three different techniques. A randomized crossover simulation study was used to compare three infant CPR techniques: the two-finger technique (TF); the two-thumb encircling technique (TTE) and the two-thumb-fist technique (TTF). 58 professional lifeguards performed three tests in pairs during a 20-min period of CPR. The rescuers performed compressions and ventilations in 15:2 cycles and changed their roles every 2 min. The variables of analysis were CPR quality components, rate of perceived exertion (RPE) and hand pain with numeric rating scale (NRS). All three techniques showed high Q-CPR results (TF: 86 ± 9%/TTE: 88 ± 9%/TTF: 86 ± 16%), and the TTE showed higher values than the TF (p = 0.03). In the RPE analysis, fatigue was not excessive with any of the three techniques (values 20 min between 3.2 for TF, 2.4 in TTE and 2.5 in TTF on a 10-point scale). TF reached a higher value in RPE than TTF in all the intervals analyzed (p < 0.05). In relation to NRS, TF showed significantly higher values than TTE and TTF (NRS minute 20 = TF 4.7 vs. TTE 2.5 & TTF 2.2; p < 0.001). In conclusion, all techniques have been shown to be effective in high-quality infant CPR in a prolonged resuscitation carried out by lifeguards. However, the two-finger technique is less efficient in relation to fatigue and hand pain compared with two-thumb technique (TF vs. TTF, p = 0.01).Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessing the efficacy of rescue equipment in lifeguard resuscitation efforts for drowningThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2016
- DrowningNew England Journal of Medicine, 2012
- A comparison of two-fingers technique and two-thumbs encircling hands technique of chest compression in neonatesJournal of Perinatology, 2011
- Two-thumb technique is superior to two-finger technique during lone rescuer infant manikin CPRResuscitation, 2010
- Better outcome after pediatric resuscitation is still a dilemmaJournal of Emergencies, Trauma, and Shock, 2010
- Outcome of Out-of-Hospital Cardiorespiratory Arrest in ChildrenPediatric Emergency Care, 2005
- Occupational fitness standards for beach lifeguards. Phase 1: the physiological demands of beach lifeguardingOccupational Medicine, 2005
- Pain: a review of three commonly used pain rating scalesJournal of Clinical Nursing, 2005
- In-water resuscitation—is it worthwhile?Resuscitation, 2004
- Towards new models of cardiopulmonary resuscitation teaching: the role of practical scenario training on surf lifesavers’ perceptions of resuscitation efficacyResuscitation, 2002