Applicability of causal dissipative hydrodynamics to relativistic heavy ion collisions
Authors:
- Pasi HuovinenPHPasi Huovinen
- Denes MolnarDMDenes Molnar
- 28 January 2009
- journal article
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review C
- Vol. 79 (1)
Abstract
We utilize nonequilibrium covariant transport theory to determine the region of validity of causal Israel-Stewart dissipative hydrodynamics (IS) and Navier-Stokes theory (NS) for relativistic heavy ion physics applications. A massless ideal gas with 2->2 interactions is considered in a 0+1D Bjorken scenario, appropriate for the early longitudinal expansion stage of the collision. In the scale invariant case of a constant shear viscosity to entropy density ratio eta/s ~ const, we find that Israel-Stewart theory is 10% accurate in calculating dissipative effects if initially the expansion timescale exceeds half the transport mean free path tau0/lambda0 > ~2. The same accuracy with Navier-Stokes requires three times larger tau0/lambda0 > ~6. For dynamics driven by a constant cross section, on the other hand, about 50% larger tau0/lambda0 > ~3 (IS) and ~9 (NS) are needed. For typical applications at RHIC energies s_{NN}**(1/2) ~ 100-200 GeV, these limits imply that even the Israel-Stewart approach becomes marginal when eta/s > ~0.15. In addition, we find that the 'naive' approximation to Israel-Stewart theory, which neglects products of gradients and dissipative quantities, has an even smaller range of applicability than Navier-Stokes. We also obtain analytic Israel-Stewart and Navier-Stokes solutions in 0+1D, and present further tests for numerical dissipative hydrodynamics codes in 1+1, 2+1, and 3+1D based on generalized conservation laws.Comment: 30 pages, 26 EPS figures, revtex stylefilKeywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Viscosity Bound and Causality ViolationPhysical Review Letters, 2008
- Viscosity in Strongly Interacting Quantum Field Theories from Black Hole PhysicsPhysical Review Letters, 2005
- What RHIC experiments and theory tell us about properties of quark–gluon plasma?Nuclear Physics A, 2005
- Collective flow signals the quark–gluon plasmaNuclear Physics A, 2005
- New forms of QCD matter discovered at RHICNuclear Physics A, 2005
- Dissipation and Elliptic Flow at Relativistic EnergiesPhysical Review Letters, 2005
- Erratum: Second Order Dissipative Fluid Dynamics for Ultrarelativistic Nuclear Collisions [Phys. Rev. Lett.88, 062302 (2002)]Physical Review Letters, 2002
- Second-Order Dissipative Fluid Dynamics for Ultrarelativistic Nuclear CollisionsPhysical Review Letters, 2002
- Shear Viscosity of Strongly CoupledSupersymmetric Yang-Mills PlasmaPhysical Review Letters, 2001
- Dissipative phenomena in quark-gluon plasmasPhysical Review D, 1985